All-Time ODAC Baseball
All-Conference Squads
1977
Player of the Year - Buddy Bailey, C, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year - Fred Selfe, Emory & Henry
| 1B | Keith Snider | LYN | C | Buddy Bailey | LYN |
| 2B | Jeff Wholey | BC | OF | Scott McGahan | LYN |
| Jeff White | R-MC | Dewayne Kitts | LYN | ||
| 3B | Dewayne Elliott | R-MC | Silas Harvey | BC | |
| SS | Ben Newell | H-SC | DH | David Bristow | R-MC |
| P | Jack Hobbs | LYN | |||
| Larry McAlexander | R-MC |
1978
Player of the Year - Dewayne Kitts, P, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year - Dr. Jim Reedy, Bridgewater
| 1B | Keith Snider | LYN | C | Buddy Bailey | LYN |
| 2B | Bill Neidermayer | H-SC | OF | Scott McGahan | LYN |
| 3B | Mike Adkins | H-SC | David Bristow | R-MC | |
| SS | Ben Newell | H-SC | Donnie Brubaker | EMC | |
| P | Larry French | BC | DH | Ted Thomas | R-MC |
| Jack Hobbs | LYN |
1979
Player of the Year - Bob Naramore, P, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year - Hugh Stephens, Randolph-Macon
| 1B | Silas Harvey | BC | C | Kevin Shinault | E&H |
| 2B | Kevin Wholey | BC | OF | Mike Adkins | H-SC |
| 3B | Wayne Robertson | LYN | Jeff McCauley | EMC | |
| SS | Alan Herman | LYN | Chip Childress | LYN | |
| P | Bob Naramore | R-MC | DH | Jeff McCauley | EMC |
1980
Player of the Year - Jim Stinnett, 3B, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year - Gerry Thomas, Lynchburg
| 1B | Mike Keating | E&H | C | Abe Naff | LYN |
| 2B | Daryl Burkholder | EMC | OF | Thad Ellis | W&L |
| 3B | Jim Stinnett | LYN | Tim Maxa | H-SC | |
| SS | Jerry Hutchinson | BC | Ted Thomas | R-MC | |
| P | Kenny Shiflett | LYN | Steve Martin | BC | |
| Scott Miller | R-MC | DH | Keith Greener | LYN |
1981
Player of the Year - Mark Puckett, 1B, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year - Gerry Thomas, Lynchburg
| 1B | Mark Puckett | BC | C | Abe Naff | LYN |
| 2B | Jim McMahon | LYN | OF | Bob Garrett | LYN |
| 3B | Jim Stinnett | LYN | Kelly Carnahan | E&H | |
| SS | Chip Childress | LYN | John Graff | BC | |
| P | Mark Smith | LYN | DH | Keith Greener | LYN |
| Tommy Thomas | BC |
1982
Player of the Year - Chip Childress, SS, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year - Gerry Thomas, Lynchburg
| 1B | Mark Puckett | BC | C | Tim Lipka | R-MC |
| 2B | Jim Moore | H-SC | OF | Kelly Carnahan | E&H |
| 3B | Lee Butler | LYN | Wayne Harrison | LYN | |
| Rob Martin | EMC | Jack Walker | R-MC | ||
| SS | Chip Childress | LYN | DH | Skip Sawyer | H-SC |
| P | Mark Smith | LYN | P | Sean Delaney | LYN |
1983
Player of the Year - Wayne Harrison, OF, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year - Gerry Thomas, Lynchburg
| 1B | Mike Smiciklas | MC | C | Terry Carson | LYN |
| 2B | Scott Duncan | LYN | Charlie Pence | BC | |
| 3B | Wayne Hall | E&H | OF | Wayne Harrison | LYN |
| SS | Lee Butler | LYN | Robin Hackemeyer | LYN | |
| P | Sean Delaney | LYN | Chris Cavalline | W&L | |
| Doug Byler | EMC | DH | Rick Rossetti | H-SC |
1984
Player of the Year - Dave Smith, P, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year - Gregg Waters, Randolph-Macon
| 1B | Jim Rice | R-MC | C | Jeff Poling | BC |
| 2B | Todd Sullivan | BC | OF | Mike Lindsay | E&H |
| 3B | Kevin Roberts | LYN | Bobby Knecht | BC | |
| SS | Dave Warrenfeltz | W&L | Percy Abell | LYN | |
| P | Jeff White | LYN | DH | Alan Propst | BC |
| Dave Smith | R-MC |
1985
Player of the Year - Jack Walker, OF, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year - Dr. Tom Kinder, Bridgewater
| 1B | Fred Heatwole | BC | C | Jeff Poling | BC |
| 2B | Scott Duncan | LYN | OF | Jack Walker | R-MC |
| 3B | Charlie Keuhn | R-MC | Mike Lindsay | E&H | |
| SS | Lee Butler | LYN | Donnie Brubaker | EMC | |
| P | Doug Byler | EMC | DH | David Jones | BC |
| Tim Landis | R-MC |
1986
Player of the Year - Tim Landis, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year - Curt Kendall, Bridgewater
| 1B | Jon Waite | H-SC | C | Pat Slifka | H-SC |
| 2B | Chuck Nelson | W&L | OF | Mike Lindsay | E&H |
| 3B | Billy Dickerson | BC | Scott Rash | R-MC | |
| SS | Barry Davis | BC | Tim Shiflett | BC | |
| P | Jeff Dean | BC | DH | James Harvey | LYN |
| Tim Landis | R-MC |
1987
Player of the Year - Troy Yancey, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year - Gregg Waters, Randolph-Macon
| 1B | Pat Shiflet | BC | C | Barry Landis | R-MC |
| 2B | Jon Fisher | LYN | OF | Brent Mitchell | BC |
| 3B | Percy Abell | LYN | Troy Yancey | R-MC | |
| SS | Jody Williams | H-SC | Tim Blake | LYN | |
| P | Steve Tozier | R-MC | DH | Charlie Kuehn | R-MC |
| Mark Lemacks | R-MC |
1988
Player of the Year - Charlie Kuehn, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year - Curt Kendall, Bridgewater
| 1B | Jon Waite | H-SC | C | Barry Landis | R-MC |
| 2B | Brian Wenger | BC | OF | Tim Shiflett | BC |
| 3B | Jason Harbison | MC | Scott Rash | R-MC | |
| SS | Jay Wampler | BC | Charlie Kuehn | R-MC | |
| P | Steve Hartley | BC | DH | Kevin Heimich | BC |
| Rob Sandford | LYN |
1989
Player of the Year - Scott Rash, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year - Louis "Weenie" Miller, Hampden-Sydney
| 1B | Pat Shiflet | BC | OF | Scott Rash | R-MC |
| 2B | Chris Dodge | LYN | Jason Byrd | BC | |
| 3B | Charlie Grant | BC | Brian Wenger | BC | |
| SS | Todd Abell | LYN | P | Tim Austin | H-SC |
| C | Greg Ecroyd | BC | Bill Dawson | LYN | |
| DH | Todd Lampman | H-SC |
1990
Co-Player of the Year - Brian Wenger, Bridgewater
Co-Player of the Year - Tom Harris, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year - Gerry Thomas, Lynchburg
| 1B | John Seamster | LYN | OF | Tom Harris | LYN |
| 2B | Rodney Cole | VWC | Jay Hicks | H-SC | |
| 3B | Marco Pollina | H-SC | Daryl Lambert | EMC | |
| SS | Brian Wenger | BC | P | Scott Spears | H-SC |
| C | William Hicks | H-SC | Steve Momorella | W&L | |
| DH | Chip Lockhart | E&H |
1991
Player of the Year - Scott Spears, Hampden-Sydney
Coach of the Year - Frank Fulton, Hampden-Sydney
| 1B | Todd Lampman | H-SC | OF | Daryl Lambert | EMC |
| 2B | Andy Moore | BC | Jay Hicks | H-SC | |
| 3B | Chris Dotolo | VWC | Jim Ciarlo | LYN | |
| SS | Brian Repki | BC | P | Scott Spears | H-SC |
| C | Joe Kansco | VWC | Jeff Motley | LYN | |
| DH | Scott Spears | H-SC |
1992
Player of the Year - Steve Foulks, Guilford
Coach of the Year - Robert Fulton, Guilford
| 1B | Steve Foulks | GC | OF | Daryl Lambert | EMC |
| 2B | Andy Moore | BC | Chad Evans | LYN | |
| 3B | Bobby Stewart | VWC | Clarence Inscore | GC | |
| SS | Chris Everett | LYN | P | Jeff Parr | LYN |
| C | Will Hicks | H-SC | Chan Whitson | GC | |
| DH | Chip Lockhart | E&H |
1993
Player of the Year - Bill Harlow, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year - Nick Boothe, Virginia Wesleyan
| 1B | Joel Morgan | BC | OF | Bill Harlow | BC |
| 2B | Anthony Doane | VWC | Jason Humrich | VWC | |
| 3B | Bobby Stewart | VWC | Cary Perkins | E&H | |
| SS | Brett Clark | E&H | P | Ty Simmons | GC |
| C | Jim Brewer | R-MC | Jim Keitel | VWC | |
| DH | Doug Kaufman | VWC |
1994
Player of the Year - Gary Sasser, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year - Nick Boothe, Virginia Wesleyan
| 1B | Jon Lockman | LYN | DH | Buck Gordon | BC |
| Kevin Rooks | VWC | OF | Gary Sasser | VWC | |
| 2B | Jason Williams | VWC | Cory Heinbaugh | BC | |
| 3B | Jerry Marshall | GC | Graig Fantuzzi | W&L | |
| SS | Anthony Doane | VWC | P | Jason Conley | BC |
| C | J.J. Bolton | LYN | Marty Stern | GC |
1995
Player of the Year - Brian Toland, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year - Gregg Waters, Randolph-Macon
| 1B | Jon Lockman | LYN | C | Jared Beck | E&H |
| 2B | Brian Toland | R-MC | OF | Ron Barkman | BC |
| 3B | Mark Hazelwood | H-SC | OF | Cory Heinbaugh | BC |
| SS | Brett Clark | E&H | OF | Kevin Schaen | LYN |
| P | Jimmy Abbott | R-MC | DH | Bates Brown | W&L |
| P | Chris Davis | BC |
1996
Player of the Year - Jared Beck, Emory & Henry
Coach of the Year - Jeff Stickley, Washington and Lee
| 1B | Shawn O'Dell | VWC | DH | Chris Davis | BC |
| 2B | Jason Keefer | H-SC | OF | Andy Dewease | E&H |
| 3B | Reid Herskovitz | R-MC | Graig Fantuzzi | W&L | |
| SS | Allen Snow | BC | Chris Sabatino | BC | |
| C | Jared Beck | E&H | P | Billy Kachuba | VWC |
| Chris Davis | BC |
1997
Player of the Year - Fella Dolby, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year - Nick Boothe, Virginia Wesleyan
| 1B | Robbi Moose | VWC | DH | Fella Dolby | VWC |
| 2B | Kevin Flanagan | VWC | OF | Christian Batcheller | W&L |
| 3B | Colin Jones | VWC | Cory Heinbaugh | BC | |
| SS | Toshi Sakamoto | GC | Maven Huffman | EMU | |
| C | Chris LeMore | VWC | P | Fella Dolby | VWC |
| Chad Edwards | R-MC |
1998
Player of the Year - Robbi Moose, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year - Dewey Lusk, Emory & Henry
| 1B | Robbi Moose | BC | DH | Tripp Boyd | R-MC |
| 2B | Kevin Flanagan | VWC | OF | Maven Huffman | EMU |
| 3B | Kevin Moore | GC | Christian Batcheller | W&L | |
| SS | Andy Wissinger | VWC | Kevin Crawford | BC | |
| C | Jason M. Austin | E&H | P | Brandon Matheny | E&H |
| Bob Weston | W&L |
1999
Player of the Year - Robbi Moose, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year - Jeff Stickley, Washington and Lee
| 1B | Robbi Moose | BC | DH | Jason Condrey | R-MC |
| 2B | Patrick Hall | W&L | OF | Richie Anderson | BC |
| 3B | Paul Sipos | E&H | Adam Leed | VWC | |
| SS | JC Caperton | VWC | John Sawyers | E&H | |
| C | Kevin Flanagan | VWC | P | Brian Corbo | VWC |
| David Sigler | W&L |
2000
Player of the Year - Robbi Moose, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year - Nick Boothe, Virginia Wesleyan
| 1B | Robbi Moose | BC | DH | Scott Hearn | BC |
| 2B | Scott James | VWC | OF | John Sawyers | E&H |
| 3B | Matt Weatherly | VWC | Kevin Moore | GC | |
| SS | Matt Clatterbuck | BC | Josh Longe | VWC | |
| C | Chip Woody | BC | P | Chad Coward | GC |
| Brian Corbo | VWC |
2001
Player of the Year - Erik Kratz, Eastern Mennonite
Rookie of the Year - Barney Quick, Eastern Mennonite
Coach of the Year - Curt Kendall, Bridgewater
| 1B | Mike Gale | EMU | DH | Roger Carpenter | VWC |
| 2B | Scott James | VWC | OF | Scott Hearn | BC |
| 3B | Barney Quick | EMU | OF | John Kreiser | VWC |
| SS | Matt Clatterbuck | BC | OF | John Rohrbough | EMU |
| C | Erik Kratz | EMU | P | David Sigler | W&L |
| P | Blair Hayden | LYN |
2002
Player of the Year - Erik Kratz, Eastern Mennonite
Rookie of the Year - T.J. Frazier, Eastern Mennonite
Coach of the Year - Curt Kendall, Bridgewater
| 1B | John Rohrbough | EMU | 2B | Brad Franklin | GC |
| 3B | Todd Lewis | BC | SS | Michael Hanson | W&L |
| OF | Scott Hearn | BC | OF | Steve Danis | GC |
| OF | Trey Gregory | H-SC | C | Erik Kratz | EMU |
| DH | John Kasiski | VWC | P | Joe Dooley | GC |
| P | Peter Dean | W&L |
2003
Player of the Year: Michael Hanson, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Brian Slate, Guilford
Coach of the Year: Jeff Stickley, Washington and Lee
| 1B | Brian Gladysz | W&L | 2B | Brian Slate | GC |
| 3B | Andrew Duffy | GC | SS | Michael Hanson | W&L |
| OF | Bryan Mulhern | W&L | OF | A.J. McCauley | GC |
| OF | Bobby Littlehale | W&L | C | Zach Bausch | W&L |
| DH | John Kasiski | VWC | P | Jason Jarrett | VWC |
| P | Peter Dean | W&L |
2004
Player of the Year: J.R. Estes, Bridgewater
Pitcher of the Year: Peter Dean, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Ricky Read, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Nick Boothe, Virginia Wesleyan
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Peter Dean, Washington and Lee
| 1B | Stephen Hatcher | VWC | 2B | Anthony Palmisano | LYN |
| 3B | Sean Ranson | LYN | SS | Shawn Abell | LYN |
| OF | J.R. Estes | BC | OF | Steven Scott | LYN |
| OF | Bryan Mulhern | W&L | C | Mike Supa | VWC |
| DH | John Kasiski | VWC | P | Derrick Rawlings | VWC |
| P | Peter Dean | W&L |
2005
Player of the Year: Lucas Jones, Lynchburg
Pitcher of the Year: John Schoenholtz, Hampden-Sydney
Rookie of the Year: Jason Bour, Hampden-Sydney
Coach of the Year: Jeff Kinne, Hampden-Sydney
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Lucas Jones, Lynchburg
| 1B | Lucas Jones | LYN | 2B | David Milller | W&L |
| 3B | Travis Beazley | R-MC | SS | Shawn Abell | LYN |
| OF | Chris Padgett | H-SC | OF | Steven Scott | LYN |
| OF | Colin Roberson | VWC | C | Jason Bour | H-SC |
| DH | Jordan Wesley | W&L | P | John Schoenholtz | H-SC |
| P | Jimmy Greene | BC |
2006
Player of the Year: Ricky Read, Bridgewater
Pitcher of the Year: Travis Beazley, Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Greg Meleski, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Nick Boothe, Virginia Wesleyan
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Brent Vuyovich, Virginia Wesleyan
Team Sportsmanship Award: Virginia Wesleyan
| 1B | Rob Bittner | GC | 2B | Jameson Jarvis | EMU |
| 3B | Mike Chelenza | GC | SS | Jono Brooks | BC |
| OF | Dan Sellers | VWC | OF | Steven Scott | LYN |
| OF | John Apperson | H-SC | C | Matt Hudgins | VWC |
| DH | Ricky Allred | VWC | P | Travis Beazley | R-MC |
| P | Ricky Read | BC |
2007
Player of the Year: Matt Hudgins, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: Chris Rivera, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Andrew Chrismer, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Jeff Kinne, Hampden-Sydney
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: David Miller, Washington and Lee
Team Sportsmanship Award: Randolph-Macon College
| 1B | Josh Michael | H-SC | 2B | Kyle Bradley | LYN |
| 3B | Greg Meleski | R-MC | SS | Jono Brooks | BC |
| OF | Ricky Allred | VWC | OF | Aswin Dhramapitaksook | VWC |
| OF | Mike Graves | BC | C | Matt Hudgins | VWC |
| DH | Richard Garland | W&L | P | Ricky Read | BC |
| P | Chris Rivera | VWC |
2008
Player of the Year: Ronnie LaBrie, Lynchburg
Co-Pitchers of the Year: Gary Bulman, Virginia Wesleyan and Byron Mendall, Randolph-Macon
Co-Rookies of the Year: Gary Bulman, Virginia Wesleyan and Byron Mendall, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Ray Hedrick, Randolph-Macon
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: James Madden, Washington and Lee
| 1B | Jon Crews | LYN | 2B | Greg Meleski | R-MC |
| 3B | Jeff Taylor | LYN | SS | Ronnie LaBrie | LYN |
| OF | Ozz Dhramapitaksook | VWC | OF | Terrence McKelvey | W&L |
| OF | Mike Wallace | R-MC | C | Will Lewis | W&L |
| DH | Charlie Hartt | R-MC | P | Gary Bulman | VWC |
| P | Byron Mendenhall | R-MC |
2009
Player of the Year: Terrence McKelvey, Washington and Lee
Co-Pitcher of the Year: Joe Devlin, Lynchburg College
Co-Pitcher of the Year: Brett Horowitz, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Jeff Stickley, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Tyler Hodges, Bridgewater
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Terrence McKelvey, Washington and Lee
| 1B | Charlie Hartt | R-MC | 2B | Phil Cadle | VWC |
| 3B | Matt Brown | H-SC | SS | John Ditore | W&L |
| OF | Chris Harpine | VWC | OF | Michael Wallace | R-MC |
| OF | Terrence McKelvey | W&L | C | C.J. Rhodes | VWC |
| DH | Kyle Wooden | GC | P | Joe Devlin | LYN |
| P | Brett Horowitz | VWC |
2010
Player of the Year: Mike Marion, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: Kyle Hicks, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Jeff Kinne, Hampden-Sydney
Rookie of the Year: Brock Shiflett, Lynchburg
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Max Axelrod, Virginia Wesleyan
| 1B | Justin Hebert | H-SC | 2B | Kevin Davis | R-MC |
| 3B | Matt Brown | H-SC | SS | Chris Martin | H-SC |
| OF | Andrew Chrismer | BC | OF | Myles Shipp | VWC |
| OF | Jeff Taylor | LYN | C | Jay Lichter | R-MC |
| DH | Mike Marion | VWC | P | Alex Foltz | BC |
| P | Kyle Hicks | R-MC |
2011
Player of the Year: Kyle Wooden, Guilford
Pitcher of the Year: Gregg Laswell, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Curt Kendall, Bridgewater
Rookie of the Year: James Womack, Lynchburg
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Pike Brynildsen, Virginia Wesleyan
| 1B | Kyle Wooden | GC | 2B | Greg Mitro | R-MC |
| 3B | Hunter Lewis | H-SC | SS | Richie Palase | LYN |
| OF | Jeb Weymouth | R-MC | OF | Jonathan Mason | BC |
| OF | Shayne Paskanik | VWC | C | Zach Harrelson | H-SC |
| DH | Will Salley | W&L | P | Gregg Laswell | W&L |
| P | Matt Morgan | LYN |
2012
Player of the Year: Jordan Walton, Randolph-Macon
Pitcher of the Year: Kevin Chandler, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Trey McCall, Emory & Henry
Rookie of the Year: Zach Whitaker, P, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Zach Fitzpatrick, C, Lynchburg
| 1B | Jordan Walton | R-MC | 2B | Josh McMillian | E&H |
| 3B | Dan Savage | LYN | SS | Jonathan Stutts | W&L |
| OF | Remington Hedgepeth | E&H | OF | Richie Palase | LYN |
| OF | Brian Kluge | RC | C | Devon Snow | BC |
| DH | Brock Shiflett | LYN | P | Kevin Chandler | BC |
| P | Zach Whitaker | H-SC |
2013
Player of the Year: Nick Fulk, Bridgewater
Pitcher of the Year: Martin Henderlite, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Curt Kendall, Bridgewater
Rookie of the Year: Mitchell Keeler, DH, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: John Macon Smith, OF, Guilford
| 1B | Alex Maragos | W&L | 2B | Corey Wallace | GC |
| 3B | Kent Peterson | GC | SS | Jonathan Stutts | W&L |
| OF | Kenneth Belgrave | VWC | OF | Nick Fulk | BC |
| OF | John Macon Smith | GC | C | Alex Mait | W&L |
| DH | Mitchell Keeler | R-MC | P | Robert Gallet | BC |
| RP | Luke Rabiej | H-SC | P | Martin Henderlite |
LYN |
2014
Player of the Year: Michael Paul, Shenandoah
Pitcher of the Year: Darrell Thompson, Shenandoah
Coach of the Year: Kevin Anderson, Shenandoah
Rookie of the Year: Nicholas Maiolo, So., DH, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: John Macon Smith, Guilford
| 1B | John Macon Smith | GC | 2B | Lee Carneal | H-SC |
| 3B | Michael Paul | SU | SS | Billy Arens | SU |
| OF | Keegan Dolan | W&L | OF | Christian Hamlett | H-SC |
| OF | Adam Posey | EMU | C | Rob Tomasulo | LYN |
| DH | Nicholas Maiolo | R-MC | P | Darrell Thompson | SU |
| RP | Glenn McLaughlin | R-MC | P | Brandon Miller | LYN |
2015
Player of the Year: Zach Bach, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: Sean Greiser, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Ben Spotts, Eastern Mennonite
Rookie of the Year: Rick Spiers, OF/P, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Jeff Gray, Hampden-Sydney
| 1B | Zach Bach | VWC | 2B | Billy Arens | SU |
| 3B | J.J. McDaniel | SU | SS | Justin Rodriguez | EMU |
| OF | Joe Hall | EMU | OF | Joe Rogers | LYN |
| OF | Ricky Pardo | SU | C | Will Black | RC |
| DH | Nolan Overby | SU | P | James Walsh | R-MC |
| RP | Austin Marzullo | EMU | P | Sean Greiser | VWC |
| UT | Rick Spiers | R-MC |
2016
Player of the Year: Travis Lodge, 3B, Randolph-Macon
Pitcher of the Year: James Walsh, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Lucas Jones, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Bryan Goodwyn, OF, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Tom Concklin, P, Washington and Lee
| 1B | Chuck Noble | GC | OF | Brandon Lineberry | E&H |
| 2B | Joe Tomasulo | LYN | OF | Kenner Berry | BC |
| 3B | Travis Lodge | R-MC | OF | Abel Arocho | SU |
| SS | Brandon Kussmaul | VWC | C | CJ Lindsay | VWC |
| DH | Nick Maiolo | R-MC | P | James Walsh | R-MC |
| RP | Phil Morse | SU | P | Tom Concklin | W&L |
| UT | Rick Spiers | R-MC |
2017
Player of the Year: Cole Migliorini, OF, Randolph-Macon
Pitcher of the Year: Colin Morse, Shenandoah
Coach of the Year: Kevin Anderson, Shenandoah
Rookie of the Year: Patrick Monteverde, P, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Joe Hall, OF, Eastern Mennonite
| 1B | Luke Nussman | SU | OF | Justin Erby | VWC |
| 2B | Trevor Denton | GC | OF | Joe Hall | EMU |
| 3B | Ryan Weston | W&L | OF | Cole Migliorini | R-MC |
| SS | Chadwick Feeley | W&L | C | Will Hylton | LYN |
| DH | Jake Loew | SU | P | Tom Concklin | W&L |
| RP | Danny Devereux | W&L | P | Colin Morse | SU |
| UT | Damon Frazier | EMU |
2018
Player of the Year: Sean Guida, OF, Roanoke
Pitcher of the Year: Colin Selby, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Ray Hedrick, Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Will Salva, P, Roanoke
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Damon Frazier, UT, Eastern Mennonite
| 1B | Joseph Tuzzolo | R-MC | OF | Ryan Duphorn | R-MC |
| 2B | Jeff Butler | R-MC | OF | Sean Guida | RC |
| 3B | Jack Howard | RC | OF | Grant Thompson | SU |
| SS | Brandon Kussmaul | VWU | C | Reece Yeargain | R-MC |
| DH | Keegan Woolford | SU | P | Jacob Pilarski | VWU |
| RP | Glen Pizzanello | VWU | P | Colin Selby | R-MC |
| UT | Damon Frazier | EMU |
2019
Player of the Year: Mike Nickles, Randolph-Macon
Pitcher of the Year: Nick Roth, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Ray Hedrick, Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Garrett Jackson, Lynchburg
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Jack Howard, 3B, Roanoke
| 1B | Jordan McDonough | VWU | OF | Shawn Nickles | R-MC |
| 2B | Chase Counts | H-SC | OF | Ben Sexton | E&H |
| 3B | Mike Nickles | R-MC | OF | Will Smith | RC |
| SS | Jacob Talley | BC | C | Tim Ortega | FC |
| DH | Matthew Spagnolo | H-SC | P | Nick Roth | R-MC |
| RP | Kevin Ledford | RC | P | Michael Zubovich | R-MC |
| UT | Jacob Pilarski | VWU |
2020
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Ryan Monson, OF, Washington and Lee
*2020 spring sports were suspended indefinitely due to COVID-19 and all-conference recognitions were not awarded.
2021
Player of the Year: Colby Martin, So., 2B, Shenandoah
Pitcher of the Year: Brandon Pond, Jr. SP, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Lucas Jones, Lynchburg
Rookie of the Year: Gavin Jones, Fy, 3B, Lynchburg
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Josh Greenway, OF, Ferrum
| 1B | Reece Yeargain | R-MC | OF | Avery Neaves | LYN |
| 2B | Colby Martin | SU | OF | Josh Greenway | FERR |
| 3B | Pearce Bucher | SU | OF | Jaylon Lee | EMU |
| SS | Frankie Ritter | SU | C | Jacob Selden | C |
| DH | Carter Plunkett | ROA | P | Brandon Pond | LYN |
| RP | Grayson Thurman | LYN | P | Matt Nickles | R-MC |
| UT | Kinston Carson | LYN |
2022
Player of the Year: Avery Neaves, Jr., OF, Lynchburg
Pitcher of the Year: Reid Long, SP, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Lucas Jones, Lynchburg
Rookie of the Year: Nick Mattfield, So, SP, Lynchburg
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Pearce Bucher, Gr., 1B, Shenandoah
| 1B | Miles Webb | R-MC | OF | Avery Neaves | LYN |
| 2B | Kyle Lisa | SU | OF | Bryce Vestal | GC |
| 3B | Carter Johnson | R-MC | OF | Jaylon Lee | EMU |
| SS | Frankie Ritter | SU | C | Ray Tricarico | EMU |
| DH | Hunter Cole | R-MC | P | Reid Long | BC |
| RP | Grayson Thurman | LYN | P | Nick Mattfield | LYN |
| UT | Brett Tharp | BC |
2023
Player of the Year: Hunter Cole, Sr., OF, Randolph-Macon
Pitcher of the Year: Jack Bachmore, Sr., RP, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Kevin Anderson, Shenandoah
Rookie of the Year: Rylan Smith, Fy., 3B, Guilford
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Mitchell Salvino, Sr., OF, Washington and Lee
| 1B | Isaiah Hairston | GC | OF | Hunter Cole | R-MC |
| 2B | Conner Butler | RC | OF | Jacob Bonzon | RC |
| 3B | Rylan Smith | RC | OF | Gavin Horning | SU |
| SS | Frankie Ritter | SU | C | Colin Smith | GC |
| DH | Brody Langlotz | RC | P | Owen Tappy | HSC |
| RP | Jack Bachmore | LYN | P | Jacob Faivre | SU |
| UT | Chase Wade | GC |