Old Dominion Athletic Conference
All-Time Men's Basketball All-Conference Teams
1977
Player of the Year: Pat Dennis, guard, W&L
Coach of the Year: Verne Canfield, W&L
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Pat Dennis | W&L | G | Miles Yoder | EMC |
| G | Wayne Davis | LC | F | Lewis Elliott | H-SC |
| F | Bob Flint | W&L | G | Mike Wenke | W&L |
| F | Ed Tiernan | H-SC | F | Jim Crawford | LC |
| C | E.D. Schechterly | LC | C | Don Berlin | W&L |
1978
Player of the Year: Pat Dennis, guard, W&L
Coach of the Year: Don Thompson, H-SC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Pat Dennis | W&L | G | Tom Jackson | H-SC |
| G | Wayne Davis | LC | F | Chris Wilbourne | BC |
| F | Ed Owens | H-SC | F | Jim Crawford | LC |
| F | Miles Yoder | EMC | F | Dave Leunig | W&L |
| C | E.D. Schechterly | LC | F | Chip Berry | LC |
1979
Player of the Year: E.D. Schechterly, center, LC
Coach of the Year: Don Thompson, H-SC and Wayne Profitt, LC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Ed Owens | H-SC | G | Carby Hoy | W&L |
| F | Rick Purcell | LC | G | Tom Jackson | H-SC |
| F | Miles Yoder | EMC | F | Chuck Ogle | E&H |
| C | L.F. Elliott | H-SC | F | Tom Jeffries | W&L |
| C | E.D. Schechterly | LC | F | Bill Creveling | BC |
1980
Player of the Year: E.D. Schechterly, center, LC
Coach of the Year: Sherman Eberly, EMC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Tim Crawford | EMC | G | Bill Shelly | H-SC |
| F | Rick Purcell | LC | F | Larry Sheets | EMC |
| F | Tom Jeffries | W&L | F | Boo Chafin | E&H |
| C | Ed Owens | H-SC | F | Chuck Ogle | E&H |
| C | E.D. Schechterly | LC | F | Drew Payne | H-SC |
1981
Player of the Year: Mike Baker, guard, RC
Coach of the Year: Ed Green, RC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Mike Baker | RC | G | Carby Hoy | W&L |
| G | Jeff Smith | BC | F | Ken Belton | RC |
| F | Jeff Kroll | H-SC | C | Gerald Holmes | RC |
| C | Jim Williamson | E&H | C | Matt McCargo | LC |
| C | Rob Smitherman | W&L | C | Rich Suttle | MC |
1982
Player of the Year: Gerald Holmes, forward, RC
Coach of the Year: Verne Canfield, W&L
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Gerald Holmes | RC | G | George Spears | W&L |
| G | Darren Maynard | BC | G | Bobby Rimmer | MC |
| C/F | Jim Williamson | E&H | G | Stephfan Allen | EMC |
| F | Larry Sheets | EMC | G | Reggie Thomas | RC |
| F | Brian Hanson | W&L | G | Jeff Huffman | LC |
1983
Player of the Year: Gerald Holmes, forward, RC
Coach of the Year: Jack Bruen, CUA
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Gerald Holmes | RC | F | Boo Chafin | E&H |
| F | Brian Hanson | W&L | C | Andy Agee | BC |
| F | Mark Kelly | H-SC | G | Darren Maynard | BC |
| F | Leonard Dow | EMC | F | Darren Heath | CUA |
| G | Reggie Thomas | RC | G | Luke D'Alessio | CUA |
1984
Player of the Year: Andy Agee, forward, BC
Coach of the Year: Mel Myers, BC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Andy Agee | BC | F | Kevin Brown | E&H |
| F | John Lee Graves | W&L | C | Jeff Bryant | LC |
| F | Leonard Dow | EMC | G | Luke D'Alessio | CUA |
| F | Tim Woodson | RC | C | John Winkler | CUA |
| G | Reggie Thomas | RC | C | Shane Abernathy | RC |
1985
Player of the Year: Leonard Dow, forward, EMC
Coach of the Year: Randy Lambert, MC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| C | Shane Abernethy | RC | G | Gregg Downer | LC |
| F | Kevin Brown | E&H | F | Keith Howard | BC |
| F | Leonard Dow | EMC | F | Lex Fitzenhagen | W&L |
| F | Deangelo McDaniel | MC | G | Paul MIlls | MC |
| G | Reggie Thomas | RC | F | Scott Shannon | W&L |
1986
Player of the Year: Kevin Brown, forward, E&H
Coach of the Year: Bob Johnson, E&H
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Kevin Brown | E&H | G | Steve Hancock | W&L |
| F | Clay Freels | MC | F | Jeff Harralson | W&L |
| F | James Pennix | RC | F | Carl Whetzel | EMC |
| F | Leonard Dow | EMC | G | Steve Posey | E&H |
| G | Costan Cheatham | LC | F | Stan Eggleston | E&H |
1987
Player of the Year: Ramsey Yeatts, forward, BC
Coach of the Year: Bill Leatherman, BC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Jefferson Harralson | W&L | G | Steve Posey | E&H |
| F | Kevin Brown | E&H | F | Carl Whetzel | EMC |
| F | Ramsey Yeatts | BC | F | Terry Tabb | LC |
| F | Stan Eggleston | E&H | F | Costan Cheatham | LC |
| C | Scott Fletcher | MC | G | Ralph Baker | H-SC |
1988
Player of the Year: Ramsey Yeatts, center, BC
Coach of the Year: Bill Leatherman, BC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| C | Ramsey Yeatts | BC | C | Scott Fletcher | MC |
| C | Stan Eggleston | E&H | C | Charles Small | RC |
| G | Ralph Baker | H-SC | C/F | James Pennix | RC |
| G | Steve Hancock | W&L | F | Stan Ballard | MC |
| C/F | Terry Tabb | LC | F | Gary Chupp | EMC |
1989
Player of the Year: Chris Jacobs, forward W&L
Coach of the Year: Verne Canfield, W&L
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Chris Jacobs | W&L | G | Gary Chupp | EMC |
| G | Ralph Baker | H-SC | F | Major Warner | E&H |
| F | Todd DeBerry | BC | G | Pat Muldowney | RC |
| F | Russell Turner | H-SC | F | Daryle Dooms | LC |
| F | Leon Hill | E&H | G | Mike Holton | W&L |
1990
Player of the Year: Leon Hill, forward, E&H
Coach of the Year: Hal Nunnally, R-MC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Leon Hill | E&H | G | Chris Jacobs | W&L |
| G | David Kagey | R-MC | F | Todd Rush | BC |
| F | Russell Turner | H-SC | G | Gary Chupp | EMC |
| F | Pat Holland | R-MC | F | Tom Kalucki | LC |
| F | Ron Pendleton | RC | G | Pat Mulquin | H-SC |
1991
Player of the Year: Dave Kagey, guard, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Bob Johnson, E&H
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Dave Kagey | R-MC | F | Daryle Dooms | LC |
| F | Leon Hill | E&H | F | Orson Williams | H-SC |
| F | Russell Turner | H-SC | F | Ed Hart | W&L |
| F | Todd Rush | BC | F | Vaughn Troyer | EMC |
| F | Pat Holland | R-MC | G | Steve Weddle | VWC |
1992
Player of the Year: Russell Turner, center, H-SC
Coach of the Year: Terry Butterfield, VWC
Freshman of the Year: Dan Rush, center, BC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| C | Russell Turner | H-SC | F | Vaughn Troyer | EMC |
| C | Troy Smith | R-MC | F | Daryle Dooms | LC |
| C | Rick Chalk | VWC | F | Rick Becker | RC |
| F | Todd Rush | BC | G | Paul Ferrell | GC |
| G | Ross Kirtley | E&H | G | Bat Barber | H-SC |
1993
Player of the Year: Troy Smith, center, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Hal Nunnally, R-MC
Freshman of the Year: Kurt Axe, guard, R-MC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| C | Troy Smith | R-MC | F | Ashley Watson | BC |
| C | Rick Chalk | VWC | F | Everett Joyner | H-SC |
| F | Hilliary Scott | RC | F | Walt Lassiter | VWC |
| F | Vaughn Troyer | EMC | G | Paul Ferrell | GC |
| F | Anthony Cummings | LC | G | Derek Elmore | E&H |
1994
Player of the Year: Hilliary Scott, forward, RC
Coach of the Year: Page Moir, RC
Freshman of the Year: Otis Tucker III, LC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Hilliary Scott | RC | G | Paul Ferrell | GC |
| F | Jeff Berry | BC | G | Kurt Axe | R-MC |
| F | Bryant Lee | RC | F | Scott Butcher | E&H |
| G | Dan Prescott | R-MC | F | Anthony Cummings | LC |
| C | Nate Schwab | H-SC | C | Rick Chalk | VWC |
| C | Dan Rush | BC | |||
1995
Player of the Year: Dan Rush, center, BC
Coach of the Year: Tony Shaver, H-SC
Freshman of the Year: Jason Light, center, E&H
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Bryant Lee | RC | F | Cam Dyer | W&L |
| F | Nate Schwab | H-SC | F | Robby Pack | GC |
| C | Dan Rush | BC | F | Shawn Peterson | GC |
| G | Kurt Axe | R-MC | C | Jason Leonard | H-SC |
| G | Dytanyon Norman | E&H | G | Otis Tucker III | LC |
1996
Player of the Year: Kurt Axe, Guard, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Bill Leatherman, BC
Freshman of the Year: Tharon Robinson, GC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Kurt Axe | R-MC | G | Jason Bishop | RC |
| G | Dytanyon Norman | E&H | G | Ryan Odom | H-SC |
| G | Craig Tutt | BC | F | Otis Tucker, III | LC |
| F | Cam Dyer | W&L | F | Nathan Davis | RMC |
| F | Jason Light | E&H | F | Nate Schwab | H-SC |
1997
Player of the Year: Jason Bishop,Guard, RC
Coach of the Year: Hal Nunnally, R-MC
Freshman of the Year: Rich Peterson, W&L
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Jason Bishop | RC | G | Bernard Hynson | VWC |
| G | Scott Powers | BC | F | Bryan Sheridan | H-SC |
| F | Otis Tucker III | LC | F | Troy Gerber | EMU |
| F | Matt Meehan | R-MC | F | Jon Maher | RC |
| C | Jason Nickerson | VWC | C | Jason Jones | BC |
1998
Kurt Axe POY: Carey Keyes, G, EMU
Coach of the Year: Tom Baker, EMU
Freshman of the Year: Jon Evans, F, GC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Carey Keyes | EMU | G | Nathan Hungate | RC |
| G | TJ Grimes | H-SC | G | Tim Petrillo | VWC |
| F | Matt Meehan | R-MC | G | Sean McAloon | R-MC |
| F | Brad Harrington | BC | F | Donald Childress | E&H |
| C | Jason Nickerson | VWC | F | Kelly Dyer | W&L |
1999
Kurt Axe POY: Jason Nickerson, C, VWC
Coach of the Year: Tony Shaver, H-SC
Freshman of the Year: Kyle Williford, C, BC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | TJ Grimes | H-SC | G | Chris Fox | H-SC |
| G | Tim Petrillo | VWC | F | David Hobbs | H-SC |
| F | Brad Harrington | BC | F | Bryan Pruett | E&H |
| F | Matt Meehan | R-MC | F | Jon Evans | GC |
| C | Jason Nickerson | VWC | C | Chris Barbour | E&H |
2000
Kurt Axe POY: TJ Grimes, G, H-SC
Coach of the Year: Tony Shaver, H-SC
Freshman of the Year: Jared Mills, R-MC
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Chris Fox | H-SC | G | Tim Petrillo | VWC |
| G | TJ Grimes | H-SC | G | Brad Dunleavy | RC |
| F | Dennis Brown | LC | F | Jason Strickland | RC |
| F | Ron Yuhasz | VWC | F | Jack Jirak | H-SC |
| C | Kyle Williford | BC | C | Jeremy Harris | H-SC |
2001
Kurt Axe POY: Ron Yuhasz, Center, VWC
Co-Coaches of the Year: Butch Estes, Guilford and Mike Rhoades, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: Kurt Bergmann, Randolph-Macon
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | |||||
| F/C | Kyle Williford | BC | G | Robby Pridgen | RC | |
| F | Colby Leftwich | RC | F | Dennis Brown | LC | |
| G | Joel Kauffman | EMU | F | Bobby Jackson | H-SC | |
| G/F | Brad Dunleavy | RC | G/F | Shane Burnette | BC | |
| C | Ron Yuhasz | VWC | F | Jared Mills | R-MC | |
| G | James Wallace | VWC | ||||
2002
Kurt Axe POY: Kyle Williford, Forward, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Mike Rhoades, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: E.J. Arrington, Eastern Mennonite
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | |||
| Kyle Williford | BC | Brandon Randall | H-SC | |
| Jared Mills | R-MC | Aron McMillian | GC | |
| James Wallace | VWC | Josh Foster | RC | |
| Kurt Bergmann | R-MC | Justin Call | E&H | |
| Robby Pridgen | RC | Josh Connor | GC | |
2003
Kurt Axe POY: Jared Mills, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Mike Rhoades, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: Justin Wansley, Randolph-Macon
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | |||
| Jared Mills | R-MC | Josh Foster | RC | |
| Robby Pridgen | RC | David Doino | VWC | |
| Justin Call | E&H | Kurt Bergmann | R-MC | |
| Jeff Monroe | H-SC | Jevon Clarke | GC | |
| Ricky Easterling | BC | Peter Warren | VWC | |
2004
Kurt Axe POY: Justin Call, Emory & Henry
Co-Coaches of the Year: Tom Palombo, Guilford and Bob Johnson, Emory & Henry
Freshman of the Year: Brandon Adair, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Justin Call, Emory & Henry
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | |||
| Justin Call | E&H | Kurt Bergmann | R-MC | |
| David Doino | VWC | Jevon Clarke | GC | |
| Ricky Easterling | BC | Kevinn Hunter | RC | |
| Jeff Monroe | H-SC | Brandon Randall | H-SC | |
| Justin Wansley | R-MC | Peter Warren | VWC | |
2005
Kurt Axe POY: Justin Wansley, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Bill Leatherman, Bridgewater
Freshman of the Year: Kerry Atkinson, Guilford
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Clay Michael, Bridgewater
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Ricky Easterling | BC | G | Ryan Pehanick | LC |
| G | Jason Sager | EMU | G | Lance Reasbeck | E&H |
| F | Brandon Adair | VWC | F | Clay Michael | BC |
| F | Justin Wansley | R-MC | F | Phillip Hawley | R-MC |
| F | Kevinn Hunter | RC | F | Genaro Lawhorn | GC |
| G | Marques Fitch | VWC | |||
2006
Kurt Axe POY: Brandon Adair, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Dave Macedo, Virginia Wesleyan
Freshman of the Year: David Carlson, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Clay Michael, Bridgewater
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Troy Kaase | H-SC | G | Ton Ton Balenga | VWC |
| F | Jason Sager | EMU | G | Jared Butler | RC |
| F | Brandon Adair | VWC | F | Clay Michael | BC |
| F | Justin Wansley | R-MC | F | Phillip Hawley | R-MC |
| F | Ben Strong | GC | G | Corey Whiting | EMU |
2007
Kurt Axe POY: Ben Strong, Guilford
Coach of the Year: Tom Palombo, Guilford
Freshman of the Year: Dominic Trawick, Bridgewater
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Matt Green, Hampden-Sydney
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Brandon Adair | VWC | G | Ton Ton Balenga | VWC |
| F | Greg Bieneman | W&L | F | Jeremy Dixon | R-MC |
| G | David Carlson | R-MC | G | Mike Edwards | H-SC |
| F | Jason Sager | EMU | F | Phillip Hawley | R-MC |
| G | Jordan Snipes | GC | F | Josh LaPorte | RC |
| F | Ben Strong | GC | C | Curtis Peery | RC |
| G | Dominic Trawick | BC | |||
2008
Kurt Axe POY: Ben Strong, Guilford
Coach of the Year: Adam Hutchinson, Washington and Lee
Freshman of the Year: Jordan Brown, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Drew Prehmus, Hampden-Sydney
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Greg Bienemann | W&L | G | Ton Ton Balenga | VWC |
| F | Tyler Fantin | VWC | F | Jeremy Dixon | R-MC |
| G | Turner King | H-SC | C | Troy Kaase | H-SC |
| G | Justin Short | R-MC | F | Josh LaPorte | RC |
| C | Ben Strong | GC | F | Brad Parkes | EMU |
| F | Mason Wooldridge | LC | G | Dominic Trawick | BC |
2009
Kurt Axe POY: Justin Short, Randolph-Macon
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Tom Palombo, Guilford
Freshman of the Year: Derrick Woods-Morrow, Randolph
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Ben Heller, Washington and Lee
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Clay Henson | GC | G | Rhett Bonner | GC |
| G | George Johnson | EMU | F | Jordan Brown | R-MC |
| G | Turner King | H-SC | G | Terrell Dixon | VWC |
| F | Curtis Peery | RC | G | Stephen Fields | VWC |
| C | Tyler Sanborn | GC | F | D.J. Hinson | EMU |
| G | Justin Short | R-MC | G | Dominic Trawick | BC |
| F | Mason Wooldridge | LC | |||
2010
Kurt Axe POY: Tyler Sanborn, Guilford
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Kirby Dean, Eastern Mennonite
Freshman of the Year: Harrison George, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Ben Goetsch, Washington and Lee
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| G | Steven Echols | LC | G | Rhett Bonner | GC |
| G | Stephen Fields | VWC | F | Brandon Braxton | R-MC |
| G | Clay Henson | GC | F | Ben Goetsch | W&L |
| W | Todd Phillips | EMU | G | George Johnson | EMU |
| C | Tyler Sanborn | GC | F | Turner King | H-SC |
| G | Dominic Trawick | BC | G | Donald Vaughn | VWC |
2011
Kurt Axe POY: Todd Phillips, Eastern Mennonite
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Clay Nunley, Randolph
Freshman of the Year: D.J. Woodmore, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Colton Hunt, Randolph
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | ||||
| F | Nathan Campbell | LC | C | Brandon Braxton | R-MC |
| F | Harrison George | H-SC | G | Melvin Felix | RC |
| G | Colton Hunt | RAND | F | Terrance Grigg | E&H |
| F | Danny Jones | R-MC | G | George Johnson | EMU |
| W | Todd Phillips | EMU | F | Donald Vaughn | VWC |
| G | Josh Pittman | GC | G | D.J. Woodmore | VWC |
2012
Kurt Axe POY: D.J. Woodmore, Virginia Wesleyan
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: David Macedo, Virginia Wesleyan
Freshman of the Year: Will Freeman, Guilford
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Colton Hunt, Randolph
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| F | Nathan Campbell | LC | F | Chris Astorga | VWC | C | Austin Chillemi | LC |
| F | Harrison George | H-SC | G | Kwasi Amponsah | RC | G | Adam Desgain | R-MC |
| G | Colton Hunt | RAND | G | Calvin Croskey | R-MC | G | Malcolm Green | E&H |
| G | D.J. Woodmore | VWC | F | J.D. Ey | W&L | F | Andrew Thorne | EMU |
| F | Donald Vaughn | VWC | F | Lamar Giggetts | R-MC | C | Khobi Williamson | H-SC |
| G | Josh Pittman | GC | G | Gabriel Lowder | GC | F | Derrick Woods-Morrow | RAND |
2013
Kurt Axe POY: Colton Hunt, Randolph
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Clay Nunley, Randolph
Freshman of the Year: Andrew Frantz,Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Colton Hunt, Randolph
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| F | Chris Astorga | VWC | F | Manny Hernandez | LC | C | Austin Chillemi | LC |
| F | Harrison George | H-SC | G | Kwasi Amponsah | RC | G | Tre' Ford | VWC |
| G | Colton Hunt | RAND | G | Andre Simon | R-MC | G | Matt McCarthy | GC |
| G | D.J. Woodmore | VWC | F | J.D. Ey | W&L | F | Ed Reddick | BC |
| F | Khobi Williamson | H-SC | F | Lamar Giggetts | R-MC | G | R.J. Sims | EMU |
| G | Josh Pittman | GC | G | Andrew Thorne | EMU | G | Chris Teasley | VWC |
2014
Kurt Axe POY: D.J. Woodmore, Virginia Wesleyan
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Nathan Davis, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: Khory Moore, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Drew Kimberly, Washington and Lee
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| F | Daniel Eacho | RC | W | Marcel Crump | EMU | G | Marcus Badger | R-MC |
| C | David Falk | EMU | G | Mike Ehilegbu | RAND | F | Alex Graves | LC |
| G | Avery Green | SU | G | Manny Hernandez | LC | F | Joe Hassell | R-MC |
| F | Andre Simon | R-MC | F | Drew Kimberly | W&L | F | Colby Heard | VWC |
| C | Khobi Williamson | H-SC | G | Matt McCarthy | GC | F | Jake Hopkins | GC |
| G | D.J. Woodmore | VWC | F | Ed Reddick | BC | G | R.J. Sims | EMU |
2015
Kurt Axe POY: Matt McCarthy, Guilford
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Nathan Davis, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: Clayton Murtha, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Daniel Eacho, Roanoke
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| G | Marcus Badger | R-MC | W | Marcel Crump | EMU | F | Austen Arnold | LC |
| C | David Falk | EMU | F | Alex Graves | LC | G | Zack Burnett | LC |
| F | Joe Hassell | R-MC | G | Greg Montgomery | VWC | G | Zach Desgain | RAND |
| G | Matt McCarthy | GC | G | Mike Murray | H-SC | C | Daniel Eacho | RC |
| G | Khory Moore | VWC | F | Ed Reddick | BC | F | Chris Hamilton | R-MC |
| F | Clayton Murtha | W&L | F | Jonny Rice | GC | G | Myles Turner | E&H |
2016
Kurt Axe POY: Alex Graves, Sr., Forward, Lynchburg
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Page Moir, Roanoke
Freshman of the Year: Alston Thompson, Fr., Forward, Guilford
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Zachary Houston, Jr., Guard, Guilford
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| G | Zack Burnett | LC | W | Malcolm Clark | SU | G | John Fitchett | RC |
| G | Zach Desgain | RAND | F | Will Freeman | GC | G | Isaiah Harris-Winn | EMU |
| F | Alex Graves | LC | G | Tim Jones | VWC | G | Zachary Houston | GC |
| F | Joey Miller | RC | G | Andy Kleinlein | W&L | F | Clayton Murtha | W&L |
| G | Khory Moore | VWC | F | Mike Murray | H-SC | F | Cameron Smith | RC |
| G | Lamont Moore | R-MC | F | Myles Turner | E&H | G | Michael Taylor | R-MC |
2017
Kurt Axe POY: Zach Burnett, Sr., G, Lynchburg
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Tom Palombo, Guilford
Freshman of the Year: Colin Molden, Fr., Emory & Henry
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Zachary Houston, Sr., Guard, Guilford
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| G | Zack Burnett | LC | F | John Caldwell | RC | G | Jake Duncan | H-SC |
| G | Malcolm Clark | SU | G | Andy Kleinlein | W&L | G | Ryan Fields | RAND |
| F | Carson Long | GC | G | C.J. Miles | RC | G | Zachary Houston | GC |
| G | Khory Moore | VWC | F | Daniel Noe | R-MC | G | Tim Jones | VWC |
| F | Clayton Murtha | W&L | F | Connor Schroeder | LC | G | RaShawn Latimer | EMU |
| F | Michael Taylor | R-MC | G | Myles Turner | E&H | F | Alston Thompson | GC |
2018
Kurt Axe POY: Josh Freund, Jr., F, Roanoke
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Josh Merkel, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: Dimetri Chambers, Fr., G, Bridgewater
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Nicholas George, Sr., F, Washington and Lee
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| F | Chase Branscomb | E&H | F | Montese Adams | R-MC | G | Dimetri Chambers | BC |
| F | Marcus Curry | GC | F | Carson Long | GC | G | Malik Crute | H-SC |
| F | Josh Freund | RC | G | C.J. Miles | RC | G | Ryan Fields | RAND |
| G | Devin Kearns | W&L | G | John Shelor | E&H | F | Roy McMillan | W&L |
| F | Clayton Murtha | W&L | G/F | Lamont Steward | VWU | G | Colin Molden | E&H |
| F | Connor Schroeder | LC | F | Alic Wynn | E&H | F | Daniel Noe | R-MC |
2019
Kurt Axe Memorial Player of the Year: Buzz Anthony, So., G, Randolph-Macon
Defensive Player of the Year: Curtis Mitchell, So., F, Washington and Lee
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Josh Merkel, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Jaylen Williams, Fy., G, Shenandoah
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Jon Nowell, Sr., F, Randolph-Macon
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| G | Buzz Anthony | R-MC | F | Kyler Gregory | GC | G | Dimetri Chambers | BC |
| F | Marcus Curry | GC | G | David Kearns | W&L | F | Tim Fisher | VWU |
| F | Josh Freund | RC | F | Grayson Midulla | R-MC | G | Sammy Hooper | RAND |
| F | Roy McMillan | W&L | F | Connor Schroeder | LYN | G | Marcus Huff | FC |
| G | Daniel Spencer | E&H | G/F | Lamont Steward | VWU | F | Carson Long | GC |
| G/F | Austin Wrighten | LYN | G | Tharon Suggs | E&H | F | Alic Wynn | E&H |
2020
Kurt Axe Memorial Player of the Year: Buzz Anthony, Jr.., G, Randolph-Macon
Defensive Player of the Year: Curtis Mitchell, Jr., F, Washington and Lee
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Josh Merkel, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Miles Mallory, Fr., F, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Buzz Anthony, Jr., G, Randolph-Macon
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| F | Kyler Gregory | GC | G | Chandler Murray | BC | F | Davrion Grier | BC |
| F | T.C. Thacker | LYN | G | Colin Molden | E&H | G | Jorden Davis | GC |
| G | Buzz Anthony | R-MC | G | Rashad Reed | FC | F/C | Jake Hahn | H-SC |
| F | Tim Fisher | VWU | F/C | Jack Wyatt | HS-C | G | Tharon Suggs | LYN |
| G | Daniel Spencer | VWU | G | Caleb Jordan | RC | F | Christopher Chaney | SU |
| G | William Brueggeman | W&L | G | Curtis Mitchell | W&L | G | Corey Pelham | VWU |
2021
Kurt Axe Memorial Player of the Year: Buzz Anthony, Jr.., G, Randolph-Macon
Defensive Player of the Year: Curtis Mitchell, Jr., F, Washington and Lee
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Josh Merkel, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Justin Kuthan, Fy., F, Roanoke
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Kajuan Madden-McAfee, Sr., G, Ferrum
| All-ODAC Team | ||||||||
| F | DJ Hill | EMU | F | Jake Hahn | H-SC | G | Efosa Edosamwan | RC |
| G | Tim Jones | EMU | G | Tharon Suggs | LYN | G | Kasey Draper | RC |
| G | Robert Holiday Jr. | E&H | F | T.C. Thacker | LYN | F | Tim Fisher | VWU |
| G | Kajuan Madden-McAfee | FC | G | Buzz Anthony | R-MC | G | Tyree Golston | VWU |
| G | Jordan Davis | GC | F | Miles Mallory | R-MC | G | William Brueggman | W&L |
| F | Liam Ward | GC | F | Ian Robertson | R-MC | F | Curtis Mitchell | W&L |
| *The ODAC men's basketball coaches named one All-ODAC Team for the 2021 spring season due to frequency of play during the COVID-19 pandemic | ||||||||
2022
Kurt Axe Memorial Player of the Year: Buzz Anthony, Sr., G, Randolph-Macon
Defensive Player of the Year: Miles Mallory, Jr., F, Randolph-Macon
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Josh Merkel, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Shod Smith, Fy., G, Bridgewater
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Kasey Draper, Jr., G/F, Roanoke
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| F | Liam Ward | GC | PG | Tim Jones | EMU | G | Shod Smith | BC |
| F | T.C. Thacker | LYN | G | Tyler Dearman | GC | F | Alec Topper | BC |
| G | Buzz Anthony | R-MC | G | Ryan Clements | H-SC | F | Julius Burch | GC |
| F | Miles Mallory | R-MC | G | Josh Talbert | R-MC | G | Tharon Suggs | LYN |
| G/F | Kasey Draper | RC | G | Jaylen Williams | SU | G | Efosa U-Edosomwan | RC |
| F | Tim Fisher | VWU | F | Robert DiSibio | W&L | F | Jack d'Entremont | W&L |
2023
Kurt Axe Memorial Player of the Year: Miles Mallory, Sr., F, Randolph-Macon
Defensive Player of the Year: Miles Mallory, Sr., F, Randolph-Macon
Bob Johnson Coach of the Year: Caleb Kimbrough, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Jabril Robinson, Fr., G, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Kasey Draper, Sr., G/F, Roanoke
| All-ODAC First Team | All-ODAC Second Team | All-ODAC Third Team | ||||||
| G | Tyler Dearman | GC | G | Shod Smith | BC | G | Alec Topper | BC |
| F | Davidson Hubbard | HSC | G | Deshone Hicks | FC | F | Jorden Davis | GC |
| F | Miles Mallory | R-MC | F | Calvin Washington | FC | F | Ryan Clements | HSC |
| G | Josh Talbert | R-MC | G | Adam Brazil | HSC | G | Danny Bickey | RAND |
| G/F | Kasey Draper | RC | F | Justin Kuthan | RC | G | Efosa U-Edosomwan | RC |
| F | Robert DiSibio | W&L | G | Omari Deveaux | VWU | F | Sam Wise | W&L |