Old Dominion Athletic Conference
All-Time Softball All-Conference Teams
1990
Player of the Year: Anna Bowers, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Aubrey Moon, Lynchburg
P | Sherry Kite | BC | SS | Donna Wenger | EMC |
P | Tabitha Williams | VWC | OF | Lori Thomas | EMC |
C | Kim Adams | VWC | OF | Sherry Catron | LYN |
1B | Nancy Hayter | BC | OF | Anna Bowers | VWC |
2B | Christy Seekford | BC | UTILITY | Tina Book | EMC |
3B | Tamela Powell | VWC |
1991
Player of the Year: Larissa Cash, Virgina Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Aubrey Moon, Lynchburg
P | Larissa Cash | VWC | SS | Jen Lukow | LYN |
P | Sherry Kite | BC | OF | Anna Bowers | VWC |
1B | Kris Wilson | VWC | OF | Jo Spitzer | BC |
2B | Stephanie Yates | VWC | OF | Patty Hough | LYN |
3B | Tamala Powell | VWC | UTILITY | Robin Gary | VWC |
1992
Player of the Year: Sarah Norman, Eastern Mennonite
Coach of the Year: Roger Mast, Eastern Mennonite
1B | Kris Wilson | VWC | OF | Anna Bowers | VWC |
2B | Stephanie Yates | VWC | OF | Jo Switzer | CC |
SS | Jen Lukow | LYN | C | Sara Norman | EMC |
3B | Theresa Northrop | BC | P | Christy Jacobs | VWC |
OF | Jen Moss | LYN | DH | Kim Hartless | LYN |
1993
Player of the Year: Michelle Good, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Tom Palombo, Virginia Wesleyan
1B | Faith McNulty | VWC | DH | Jen Moss | LYN |
2B | Betsy Boardwine | BC | P | Patti Walsh | VWC |
SS | Mary Miller | VWC | C | Kim Kumpf | VWC |
3B | Tamela Powell | VWC | |||
OF | Michelle Good | BC | |||
Kris Wilson | VWC | ||||
Anna Bowers | VWC |
1994
Player of the Year: Jennifer Mongold, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Aubrey Moon, Lynchburg
1B | Jennifer Mongold | BC | DP | Jen Moss | LYN |
2B | Jen Kinel | VWC | DP | Lisa Newnam | VWC |
3B | Misti Fulk | BC | OF | Kerri Johnson | BC |
3B | Meredith Byrum | VWC | OF | Katie Johansen | LYN |
SS | Kelly Fackler | LYN | OF | Kris Wilson | VWC |
SS | Jen Kooker | EMC | P | Monica Saltarelli | VWC |
C | Michelle Gagnon | EMC | |||
C | Kim Kumpf | VWC |
1995
Player of the Year: Kelly Fackler, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Aubrey Moon, Lynchburg
1B | Jackie Cordery | VWC | P | Julie Fennell | LYN |
2B | Summer Mantz | EMU | P | Monica Saltarelli | VWC |
SS | Kelly Fackler | LYN | OF | Catherine Patterson | LYN |
3B | Dawn Gibson | LYN | OF | LaDonna Flanagan | VWC |
C | Salita Sullivan | BC | OF | Stacy Clark | BC |
DP | Lisa Newnam | VWC |
1996
Player of the Year: Julie Fennell, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Donnie Fulk, Bridgewater
1B | Misti Fulk | BC | P | Julie Fennell | LYN |
2B | Betsy Boardwine | BC | P | Sasha Morris | BC |
SS | Kelly Fackler | LYN | OF | Stacy Clark | BC |
3B | Dawn Gibson | LYN | OF | Summer Mantz | EMU |
C | Lisa Newnam | VWC | OF | Catherine Patterson | LYN |
DP | Shane Branum | E&H |
1997
Player of the Year: Kelly Fackler, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Valerie Kepner, Virginia Wesleyan
1B | Ann Pickett | E&H | P | Jamie Kery | BC |
2B | Laura Emery | LYN | P | Monica Saltarelli | VWC |
SS | Kelly Fackler | LYN | OF | Andrea Eger | BC |
3B | Dawn Gibson | LYN | OF | Melissa Clark | LYN |
C | Lisa Newnam | VWC | OF | Lisa Paternite | VWC |
DP | Nikki Potter | RC |
1998
Player of the Year: Amy Layman, Roanoke
Coach of the Year: Alan Bayse, Roanoke
1B | Colleen Reid | BC | P | Amy Layman | RC |
2B | Shannon Ingle | BC | P | Heidi Hill | VWC |
SS | Kristi Maupin | E&H | OF | Stacy Clark | BC |
3B | Kari Whitney | RC | OF | Trena Liggon | LYN |
C | Amy Foltz | EMU | OF | Alyson Mazur | VWC |
C | Holly Morris | RC | DP | Karla Alderfer | EMU |
1999
Player of the Year: Amy Layman, Roanoke
Coach of the Year: Alan Bayse, Roanoke
1B | Colleen Reid | BC | P | Amy Layman | RC |
2B | Kelly Gouldthorpe | RC | P | Heidi Hill | VWC |
SS | Sarah French | BC | OF | Crystal Hileman | RC |
3B | Samantha Green | VWC | OF | Trena Liggon | LYN |
Kari Whitney | RC | OF | Kelly Lupton | VWC | |
DP | Marcie Poff | RC | C | Holly Morris | RC |
2000
Player of the Year: Kari Whitney, Roanoke
Coach of the Year: Alan Bayse, Roanoke
1B | Colleen Reid | BC | P | Amy Layman | RC |
2B | Kelly Gouldthorpe | RC | P | Kelly Rust | VWC |
SS | Sarah French | BC | OF | Trena Liggon | LYN |
3B | Kari Whitney | RC | OF | Cara Carpenter | BC |
C | Holly Morris | RC | OF | Kelly Lupton | VWC |
DP | Shanna Scruggs | LYN |
2001
Player of the Year: Amy Layman, Roanoke
Co-Coaches of the Year: Alan Bayse, Roanoke; Dawn Gibson, Lynchburg
1B | Colleen Reid | BC | P | Amy Layman | RC |
1B | Lisa Wasiloff | RC | P | Denise Goode | BC |
2B | Shelley Wineken | VWC | OF | Crystal Heilman | RC |
SS | Sarah Cordill | E&H | OF | Cara Carpenter | BC |
3B | Crystal Berry | RC | OF | Kelly Lupton | VWC |
C | Holly Morris | RC | UT | Nikki Rowe | VWC |
2002
Player of the Year: Sarah Cordill, Emory & Henry
Rookie of the Year: Kim Rowe, Roanoke
Coach of the Year: Alan Bayse, Roanoke
P | Erin Smith | RC | P | Jessica Worsham | RC |
C | Kameron Tucker | BC | 2B | Shelley Wineken | VWC |
1B | Kim Rowe | RC | 3B | Amy Zachary | RC |
SS | Sarah Cordill | E&H | OF | Crystal Hileman | RC |
OF | Crystal Berry | RC | OF | Crystal Hall | LYN |
DP | Rachel Capozzi | RC | UT | Kelly Rust | VWC |
2003
Player of the Year: Michelle Edelen, Lynchburg
Rookie of the Year: Brittany Edelen, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Dawn Simmons, Lynchburg
P | Michelle Edelen | LYN | P | Priscilla Hill | RC |
C | Amy Zachary | RC | 2B | Robin O'Connor | RC |
1B | Christy Mays | LYN | 3B | Rachel Capozzi | RC |
SS | Sarah Cordill | E&H | OF | Mandy Smith | E&H |
OF | Crystal Hall | LYN | OF | Crystal Berry | RC |
DP | Kameron Tucker | BC | UT | Brittany Edelen | LYN |
2004
Player of the Year: Kim Rowe, Roanoke
Pitcher of the Year: Jen Overstreet, Lynchburg
Rookie of the Year: Caroline Cubbage, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Dawn Simmons, Lynchburg
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Sarah Caldwell, Emory & Henry
P | Jen Overstreet | LYN | P | Sarah Caldwell | E&H |
C | Brittany Edelen | LYN | 2B | Laura Gonder | LYN |
1B | Kim Rowe | RC | 3B | Morgan Austin | R-MC |
SS | Sarah Cordill | E&H | OF | Lauren Lancaster | LYN |
OF | Ashley Neese | E&H | OF | Crystal Berry | RC |
DP | Caroline Cubbage | LYN | UT | Amy Zachary | RC |
2005
Player of the Year: Christy Mays, Lynchburg
Pitcher of the Year: Lyndsi Craig, Roanoke
Rookie of the Year: Jennifer Hall, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Dawn Simmons, Lynchburg
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Christy Mays, Lynchburg
P | Lyndsi Craig | RC | P | Becky Sowell | VWC |
C | Brittany Edelen | LYN | 2B | Robin O'Connor | RC |
1B | Christy Mays | RC | 3B | Lindsay Ware | BC |
SS | Brooke Barker | E&H | OF | Lauren Lancaster | LYN |
OF | Jennifer Hall | BC | OF | Jennifer Franklin | GC |
DP | Caroline Cubbage | LYN |
2006
Player of the Year: Caroline Cubbage, Lynchburg
Pitcher of the Year: Becky Sowell, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Kaitlyn Bowman, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Donnie Faulk, Bridgewater
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Amy Gillis, Roanoke
P | Lyndsi Craig | RC | P | Becky Sowell | VWC |
C | Laura Barry | BC | 2B | Tamara Poles | RC |
1B | Kristin Swank | LYN | 3B | Lindsay Ware | BC |
SS | Loren Messick | RC | OF | Kaitlyn Bowan | BC |
OF | Caroline Cubbage | LYN | OF | Mandy Nixon | VWC |
DP | Brittany Edelen | LYN |
2007
Player of the Year: Caroline Cubbage, Lynchburg
Pitcher of the Year: Lisa Rhodes, Bridgewater
Rookie of the Year: Kelsey Ruitenberg, Roanoke
Co-Coach of the Year: J.D. McCurdy, Eastern Mennonite and Kevin Proffitt, Randolph-Macon
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Amy Gillis, Roanoke
P | Lisa Rhodes | BC | P | Natasha Viafora | EMC |
C | Laura Barry | BC | 2B | Kate Reitz | BC |
1B | Krysal Ellis | SBC | 3B | Lindsay Ware | BC |
SS | Loren Messick | RC | OF | Caroline Cubbage | LYN |
OF | Hillary Hudgins | RC | OF | Jennifer Hall | BC |
DP | Caity Butler | BC |
2008
Player of the Year: Elizabeth Perkins, Lynchburg
Pitcher of the Year: Brittaney Brown, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Katie Bruce, Lynchburg
Coach of the Year: Dennis Shores, Guilford
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Mandy Nixon, Virginia Wesleyan
P | Brittaney Brown | VWC | P | Katie Bruce | LYN |
C | Miranda White | EMC | 2B | Tamara Poles | RC |
1B | Kelly Hale | GC | 3B | Elizabeth Perkins | LYN |
SS | Loren Messick | RC | OF | Kaitlyn Bowman | BC |
OF | Hillary Hudgins | RC | OF | Mandy Nixon | VWC |
DP | Caity Butler | BC |
2009
Player of the Year: Lindsay Cross, Randolph
Pitcher of the Year: Barbie Miles, Lynchburg
Rookie of the Year: Teresa Dalton, Randolph
Coach of the Year: Jen Steele, Randolph
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Brittany Allsop, Lynchburg
P | Ashley Gills | BC | P | Barbie Miles | LYN |
C | Caity Butler | BC | 2B | Kristy White | VWC |
1B | Lindsay Cross | RAND | 3B | Ami Hutcherson | GC |
SS | Taylor Walker | LYN | OF | Brittany Allsop | LYN |
OF | Kaitlyn Bowman | BC | OF | Lauren Duguay | LYN |
DP | Emily Morris | BC |
2010
Player of the Year: Lauren Duguay, Lynchburg
Pitcher of the Year: Brittaney Brown, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Leona Rainey, Roanoke
Coach of the Year: J.D. McCurdy, Eastern Mennonite
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Lauren Duguay, Lynchburg
P | Brittany Brown | VWC | P | Katie Bruce | LYN |
C | Jaclyn Quinn | VWC | 2B | Kristy White | VWC |
1B | Laura Bauer | R-MC | 3B | Lauren Childress | BC |
SS | Taylor Walker | LYN | OF | Lauren Duguay | LYN |
OF | Kimberly Keys | GC | OF | Leona Rainey | RC |
DP | Lisa Scruggs | RC |
2011
Player of the Year: Lauren Childress, Bridgewater
Pitcher of the Year: Lisa Lee, Eastern Mennonite
Rookie of the Year: McKenzie Creech, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Brandon Elliott, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Lauren Childress, Bridgewater
P | McKenzie Creech | VWC | P | Lisa Lee | EMU |
C | Jaclyn Quinn | VWC | 2B | Emily Morris | BC |
1B | Jessica Sullivan | EMU | 3B | Lauren Childress | BC |
SS | Hillary Rees | BC | OF | Molly Smith | EMU |
OF | Lauren Stevenson | RAND | OF | Leona Rainey | RC |
DP | Sara Jenkins | EMU | U | Stephanie Clark | RC |
2012
Player of the Year: Tori Higginbotham, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: Kristina Karagiorgis, Virginia Wesleyan
Co-Rookies of the Year: Kelly Higbie, Roanoke and Kristina Karagiorgis, Virginia Wesleyan
Co-Coaches of the Year: Brandon Elliott, Virginia Wesleyan and Mike Mitchell, Roanoke
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Alea Bier, Roanoke
P | Kristina Karagiorgis | VWC | P | Kelly Higbie | RC |
C | Felice Lowery | R-MC | 2B | Kelly Keys | VWC |
1B | Alea Bier | RC | 3B | Brianna Bertovich | VWC |
SS | Ashley Gardner | RAND | OF | Hollee Warlitner | RC |
OF | Tori Higginbotham | VWC | OF | Leona Rainey | RC |
DP | Sarah Heretick | BC | U | Jaclyn Quinn | VWC |
2013
Player of the Year: Tori Higginbotham, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: MacKenzie Creech, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Kimberly Brady, Shenandoah
Coach of the Year: Dawn Simmons, Lynchburg
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Alea Bier, Roanoke
P | MacKenzie Creech | VWC | P | Heather Jenkins | BC |
C | Madison Gilman | R-MC | 2B | Kelly Keys | VWC |
1B | Alea Bier | RC | 3B | Hannah Bays | E&H |
SS | Sharese Jarvis | R-MC | OF | Kimberly Brady | SU |
OF | Tori Higginbotham | VWC | OF | Leona Rainey | RC |
DP | Cassie Phillips | LYN | U | Courtney Allman | EMU |
2014
Player of the Year: Tori Higginbotham, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: Kristina Karagiorgis, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Hunter Glavé, Randolph
Coach of the Year: Brandon Elliott, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Melanie Tenney, Lynchburg
P | MacKenzie Creech | VWC | P | Kristina Karagiorgis | VWC |
C | Taylor Galvin | VWC | 2B | Cynthia Hayes | GC |
1B | Hunter Glavé | RAND | 3B | Kayla Dost | VWC |
SS | Sharese Jarvis | R-MC | OF | Aislinn Lucas | EMU |
OF | Tori Higginbotham | VWC | OF | Christine Simon | R-MC |
DP | Hannah Cook | RAND | U | Marty WiLYNox | GC |
2015
Player of the Year: Courtney Bogan, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: Kristina Karagiorgis, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Nelda Bagley, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Brandon Elliott, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Laura Hall, Guilford
P | Kelly Higbie | RC | P | Kristina Karagiorgis | VWC |
C | Madison Gilman | R-MC | 2B | Caroline Barnette | GC |
1B | Cassetty Howerin | VWC | 3B | Kayla St. John | LYN |
SS | Sharese Jarvis | R-MC | OF | Aislinn Lucas | EMU |
OF | Leah Elswick | E&H | OF | Courtney Bogan | VWC |
DP | Lisa Mitro | SU | U | Danielle Powell | LYN |
2016
Player of the Year: Kimberly Brady, OF, Shenandoah
Pitcher of the Year: Kandis Kresinske, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Kandis Kresinske, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: J.D. McCurdy, Eastern Mennonite
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Laura Hall, Guilford
P | Mary Shipp | VWC | P | Kandis Kresinske | VWC |
C | Madison Gilman | R-MC | 1B | Cassetty Howerin | VWC |
2B | Leslie Bourgeois | LYN | SS | Kiersten Richardson | VWC |
3B | Mariah Foltz | EMU | OF | Kimberly Brady | SU |
OF | Skylar Dickens | LYN | OF | Courtney Bogan | VWC |
DP | Caley Hodge | E&H | U | Mackenzie Chitwood | LYN |
2017
Player of the Year: Cassetty Howerin, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: Hanna Hull, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Hanna Hull, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Brandon Elliott, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Danielle Loving, Emory & Henry
P | Emily Kendrick | E&H | P | Hanna Hull | VWC |
C | Jessica Lindsay | VWC | 1B | Cassetty Howerin | VWC |
2B | Caroline Barnette | GC | SS | Danielle Loving | E&H |
3B | Kaylah Duplain | VWC | OF | Kayli Blankenship | GC |
OF | Sabrina Moreno | GC | OF | Makayla Carver | GC |
DP | Mikalia Guard | BC | U | Sydney Reath | EMU |
2018
Player of the Year: Madison Glaubke, Virginia Wesleyan
Pitcher of the Year: Hanna Hull, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Madie Rhoads, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Brandon Elliott, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Erin Anderson, Emory & Henry
P | Hanna Hull | VWU | P | Candace Whittemore | R-MC |
C | Sami Davidson | R-MC | 1B | Cassetty Howerin | VWU |
2B | Leslie Bourgeois | LYN | SS | Kiersten Richardson | VWU |
3B | Stephanie Carroll | BC | OF | Erin Anderson | E&H |
OF | Makayla Carver | GC | OF | Madison Glaubke | VWU |
DP | Lauren Morris | RAND | U | Beth Ford | VWU |
C | Brittany Coffey | LYN | OF | Katie Smith | RC |
2019
Player of the Year: Makayla Carver, Guilford
Pitcher of the Year: Hanna Hull, Virginia Wesleyan
Rookie of the Year: Anna Thomas, Emory & Henry
Coach of the Year: Brandon Elliott, Virginia Wesleyan
Co-ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Taylor Belknap, Lynchburg
Co-ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Natalie Conrad, Guilford
P | Hanna Hull | VWU | P | Carla Hall | VWU |
C | Jessica Lindsay | VWU | 1B | Kendall Varner | E&H |
2B | Maddie Stone | R-MC | SS | Savannah Wood | R-MC |
3B | Julia Sinnett | VWU | 3B | Taylor Mabry | LYN |
OF | Makayla Carver | GC | OF | Madison Glaubke | VWU |
OF | Rebecca Hensley | RC | U | Jessica Goldyn | VWU |
DP | Brittany LaPrade | R-MC | 1B | Mackenzie Chitwood | LYN |
2B | Katelyn Biando | VWU |
2020
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Hanna Hull, Virginia Wesleyan
*2020 spring sports were suspended indefinitely due to COVID-19 and all-conference recognitions were not awarded.
2021
ODAC Player of the Year: Jessica Goldyn, Sr., C, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC Pitcher of the Year: Hanna Hull, Gr., Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC Coach of the Year: Brandon Elliott, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Emily Seale, Fy., P, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Kayla Hugate, Gr., SS, Lynchburg
P | Jada Karnes | RC | P | Hannah Hull | VWU |
C | Jessica Goldyn | VWU | 1B | Karlee Fretz | VWU |
2B | Katelyn Biando | VWU | 3B | Katrina Martin | BC |
SS | Julia Sinnett | VWU | OF | Nicole Cox | E&H |
OF | Julie Fassl | VWU | OF | Madison Glaubke | VWU |
DP | Alex Braun | E&H | U | Danielle Stewart | VWU |
P | Alex Braun | E&H | OF | Ariana Rolle | VWU |
2022
ODAC Player of the Year: Julia Sinnett, Sr., 3B, Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC Pitcher of the Year: Gracie Ellis, Fr., Randolph-Macon
ODAC Coach of the Year: Dawn Simmons, Lynchburg
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Gracie Ellis, Fr., Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Sophie Tully, Jr., 1B, Lynchburg
P | Gracie Ellis | R-MC | P | Jada Karnes | RC |
C | Sarah Wimer | BC | 1B | Sophie Tully | LYN |
2B | Ashley Hailey | LYN | 3B | Julia Sinnett | VWU |
SS | Delaney Nuckols | RAND | OF | Dominique Irving | RAND |
OF | Naomi Sadler | R-MC | OF | Ariana Rolle | VWU |
DP | Diane Mahiai | RAND | U | Shanan Hester | RC |
1B | Rilee Baughan | R-MC | 2B | Caitlyn Ray | GC |
2023
ODAC Player of the Year: Rilee Baughan, Sr., Randolph-Macon
ODAC Pitcher of the Year: Gracie Ellis, So., Randolph-Macon
ODAC Coach of the Year: Mike Mitchell, Roanoke
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Laci Campbell, Fy., Virginia Wesleyan
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Gracie Ellis, So., Randolph-Macon
P | Gracie Ellis | R-MC | P | Lauren Bible | VWU |
C | Sarah Wimer | BC | 1B | Samantha Hensley | EMU |
2B | Laci Campbell | VWU | 3B | Alison Pollack | VWU |
SS | Delaney Nuckols | RAND | OF | Grace Calus | GC |
OF | Gracie Dooley | LYN | OF | Sarah Prosser | VWU |
DP | Taryn Campbell | RAND | U | Rilee Baughan | R-MC |
P | Jada Karnes | RC | OF | Amanda Lanyon | R-MC |