Softball began as a conference sport in the spring of 1990 with four teams vying for the ODAC title. The conference tournament was insituted in 1990 and the winner of the tournament each year is named the ODAC champion. Since 1999, the Conference champion has received a bid into the NCAA Tournament Bracket.

1990
Eastern Mennonite (3-7, 19-15)
defeated Virginia Wesleyan 11-6

1991
Virginia Wesleyan (8-2, 29-9)
defeated Eastern Mennonite 8-1

1992
Virginia Wesleyan (11-3, 27-18)
defeated Eastern Mennonite 12-4

1993
Virginia Wesleyan (9-3, 22-14)
defeated Lynchburg 8-4

1994
Lynchburg (7-5, 22-17)
defeated Bridgewater 7-2

1995
Lynchburg (13-3, 25-17)
defeated Bridgewater 3-2

1996
Lynchburg (13-2, 29-10)
defeated Bridgewater 9-0

1997
Virginia Wesleyan (9-1, 22-13)
the final game of the tournament was canceled due to inclement weather and the regular season champion was named the conference champion (VWC).

1998
Virginia Wesleyan (10-0, 25-15)
defeated Roanoke 7-0

1999
Roanoke (13-1, 34-9)
defeated Bridgewater 5-3

2000
Roanoke (13-1, 43-5)
defeated Bridgewater 1-0

2001
Roanoke (12-2, 42-11)
defeated Virginia Wesleyan, 7-6

2002
Roanoke (13-1, 38-5)
defeated Lynchburg, 9-3

2003
Emory & Henry (12-4, 22-12)
defeated Virginia Wesleyan, 2-0

2004
Roanoke
defeated Virginia Wesleyan, 4-3

2005
Roanoke
defeated Lynchburg, 6-3

2006
Roanoke
defeated Lynchburg, 4-3

2007
Lynchburg
defeated Bridgewater, 7-4

2008
Lynchburg
defeated Virginia Wesleyan, 4-1

2009
Lynchburg
defeated Eastern Mennonite, 4-1

2010
Eastern Mennonite
defeated Virginia Wesleyan, 5-1

2011
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Randolph, 7-0

2012
Roanoke
defeated Bridgewater, 7-2

2013
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Shenandoah, 8-6 (19 innings)

2014
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Randolph-Macon, 5-2

2015
Randolph-Macon
defeated Lynchburg, 7-1

2016
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Eastern Mennonite, 10-9 (9 innings)

2017
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Emory & Henry, 2-0

2018
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Emory & Henry, 6-0

2019
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Randolph-Macon, 8-2

2020
*2020 spring sports were suspended indefinitely and championships were not conducted due to COVID-19.

2021
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Lynchburg, 2-0 (4-0, 9-1 in 5 inn.)

2022
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Roanoke, 1-0

2023
Randolph-Macon
defeated Roanoke, 2-0 in best of three series (4-2, 4-3)

Total Number of Championships: