All-Time All-ODAC Women's Basketball Teams
1983
Player of the Year: Debbie Litten, F, BC
Coach of the Year: Susan Dunagan, RC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Debbie Litten | BC | G | Tina Phillips | RC |
| C | Betty Jackson | R | G | Bronie Reynolds | E&H |
| G | Ann Harwood | RC | F | Tara Barasel | LC |
| G | Wanda Morris | BC | G | Jill Basinger | EMC |
| C | Claudia Carter | HC | C | Kaye Turner | E&H |
1984
Player of the Year: Kaye Turner, F, E&H
Coach of the Year: Joy Scruggs, E&H
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Kaye Turner | E&H | C | Marian Morris | EMC |
| F | Mary Beth Harvey | RC | G | Koko Otey | LC |
| F | Goldie Dodson | MBC | G | Deana Moren | EMC |
| G | Bronie Reynolds | E&H | F | Tina Beasley | LC |
| C | Nancy Perkins | MBC | G | Leslie Secrist | RC |
1985
Player of the Year:Vickie Zimmerman, F/C, RC
Coach of the Year: Sandy Brownscombe, EMC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| C | Carolyn Foster | E&H | G | Diana Beard | BC |
| G/F | Koko Otey | LC | F | Tina Beasley | LC |
| G | Deana Moren | EMC | F | Pat Ficenec | E&H |
| G/F | Robin Weems | MBC | C/F | Marian Morris | EMC |
| F/C | Vickie Zimmerman | RC | G | Lesley Secrist | RC |
1986
Player of the Year: Deana Moren, F, EMC
Coach of the Year: Laura Mapp, BC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Deana Moren | EMC | G | Christy Shelton | MBC |
| F | Linda Burkhart | EMC | C | Marian Morris | EMC |
| F | Vicki Zimmerman | RC | F | Margaret Smith | R-MWC |
| C | Carolyn Foster | E&H | F | Anne Wright | E&H |
| G | Sara McCloskey | RC | G | Diana Beard | BC |
1987
Player of the Year: Tamsen Klein, F, E&H
Coach of the Year: Laura Mapp, BC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Tamsen Klein | E&H | G | Suzie French | EMC |
| C | Anne Wright | E&H | G | Diana Beard | BC |
| F | Beth Kitts | BC | F | Alice Apperson | RC |
| F | Jolene Cline | BC | G | Christy Shelton | MB |
| G | Amy Morgan | HC | G | Karen Martin | EMC |
|
|
|
|
C | Charimane Martin | RC |
|
|
|
|
G | Sarah Lewis | R-MWC |
1988
Player of the Year: Alice Apperson, F, RC
Coach of the Year: Susan Dunagan, RC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Tamsen Klein | E&H | C | Anne Wright | E&H |
| F | Alice Apperson | RC | C | Marie Hess | BC |
| F | Ann Wenger | EMC | C-F | Robin Gaines | HC |
| G | Suzie French | EMC | F | Tracey Driscoll | RC |
| G | Amy Morgan | HC | F | Meredith Monsinger | R-MWC |
|
|
|
|
F | Jolene Cline | BC |
|
|
|
|
G | Cindy Burkett | E&H |
1989
Player of the Year: Alice Apperson, F, RC
Coach of the Year: Marie Lewis, LC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Anne Wright | E&H | F | Robin Gaines | HC |
| G | Melody Derrow | BC | F | Kelly Worley | BC |
| F | Alice Apperson | RC | G | Missy Hensley | EMC |
| G | Cindy Burkett | E&H | G | Karen Martin | EMC |
| F | Tracey Driscoll | RC | G | Fonda Harlow | BC |
1990
Player of the Year: Stacy Carr, VWC
Coach of the Year: Susan Dunagan, RC
| First Team | Second Team | ||
| Stacy Carr | VWC | Pam Conk | R-MC |
| Melody Derrow | BC | Missy Hensley | EMC |
| Karen Jenkins | RC | Ann Kirk | E&H |
| Debbie Jones | RC | Meredith Monsinger | R-MWC |
| Keisha Bell | R-MC | Donna Cogar | RC |
1991
Player of the Year: Karen Jenkins, C, RC
Coach of the Year: Susan Dunagan, RC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| C | Karen Jenkins | RC | G | Debbie Jones | RC |
| G | Melody Derrow | BC | F | Robin Gaines | HC |
| G | Missy Hensley | EMC | G | Martha Sainz | VWC |
| F | Pam Conk | R-MC | G | Lawan Epperson | LC |
| F | Jennifer Jones | RC | C | Bekkie Siebel | R-MC |
1992
Player of the Year: Donna Cogar, F, RC
Rookie of the Year: Becca Nissley, G, EMC
Coach of the Year: Tom Palombo, VWC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| C | Brenda Davis | GC | F | Jenn Jones | RC |
| F | Pam Conk | R-MC | G | Trisha Weatherholtz | BC |
| F | Donna Cogar | RC | G | Cathy Durham | E&H |
| G | Missy Hensley | EMC | G | Serena Beedie | HC |
| G | Martha Sainz | VWC | G | Lawan Epperson | LC |
1993
Player of the Year: Brenda Davis, C, GC
Rookie of the Year: Jenn Kohler, G, R-MC
Co-Coaches of the Year: Susan Dunagan, RC ; Laura Mapp, BC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| C | Brenda Davis | GC | F | Heather Conley | E&H |
| F | Debbie Puch | RC | F | Katy Parrish | R-MC |
| G | Trisha Weatherholtz | BC | G | Amy Saunders | RC |
| G | Serena Beedie | HC | G | Jenn Kohler | R-MC |
| G | Martha Sainz | VWC | G | Becca Nissley | EMC |
1994
Player of the Year: Brenda Davis, C, GC
Rookie of the Year: Kelly Fackler, C, LC
Co-Coaches of the Year: Susan Dunagan, RC; Carroll LaHaye, R-MC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| C | Brenda Davis | GC | C | Kiersten Schnacke | R-MWC |
| C | Kelly Fackler | LC | C | Crystal Wilson | RC |
| G | Jenn Kohler | R-MC | G | Amy Beisch | VWC |
| G | Kristie Workman | RC | F | Katy Parrish | R-MC |
| G | Kay Caldwell | RC | F | Christie Osborne | BC |
1995
Player of the Year: Laura Haynes, C, GC
Rookie of the Year: Laura Haynes, C, GC
Coach of the Year: Barb Bausch, GC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Kelly Fackler | LC | F | Bari Nixon | GC |
| C | Laura Haynes | GC | C | Jackie Greene | E&H |
| C | Crystal Wilson | RC | C | Katy Parrish | R-MC |
| G | Jenn Kohler | RMC | G | Amy Beisch | VWC |
| G | Marcee Hufton | RC | G | Keri Bontrager | EMU |
1996
Player of the Year: Jenn Kohler, R-MC
Rookie of the Year: Aimee Beightol, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Carroll LaHaye, R-MC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Jenn Kohler | R-MC | G | Jennifer Young | BC |
| G | Aimee Beightol | R-MC | G | Anika Egli | EMU |
| G | Marcee Hufton | RC | G | Keri Bontrager | EMU |
| F | Jackie Greene | E&H | F | Jennifer Jensen | R-MWC |
| C | Laura Haynes | GC | F | Lori Boyd | RC |
1997
Player of the Year: Amy Athey, RC
Rookie of the Year: Tara Carleton, R-MWC
Coach of the Year: Jean Willi, BC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Anika Egli | EMU | G | Suzanne Moore | RC |
| G | Angie Simpkins | E&H | G | Jennifer Young | BC |
| C | Amy Athey | RC | F | Tara Carleton | R-MWC |
| C | Laura Haynes | GC | F | Susan Doyle | R-MC |
| C | Kristie Olson | BC | F | LeeAnna Lillefloren | VWC |
|
|
|
|
F | Bari Nixon | GC |
1998
Player of the Year: Laura Haynes, GC
Rookie of the Year: Jamie Tanner, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Jo Todd, R-MWC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Jennifer Young | BC | G | Allison Beightol | R-MC |
| G | Nancy Mattox | VWC | F | Jamie Tanner | R-MC |
| F | Connie Ritchie | BC | F | Leslie Buhrman | R-MC |
| F | Tara Carleton | R-MWC | F | Anika Egli | EMU |
| C | Laura Haynes | GC | C | Laurie Miller | EMU |
1999
Player of the Year: Tara Carleton, R-MWC
Rookie of the Year: Jessica Mentz , W&L
Coach of the Year: Carroll LaHaye, R-MC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Aimee Beightol | R-MC | G | Allison Beightol | R-MC |
| G | Nancy Mattox | VWC | G | Carrie McConnell | RC |
| F | Tara Carleton | R-MWC | F | Cheryl Rhodes | RC |
| C | Renee' Zando | R-MC | F | Connie Ritchie | BC |
| C | Amanda Kyger | BC | C | Jessica Mentz | W&L |
2000
Player of the Year: Arden Miller. GC
Rookie of the Year: Emily Mullet, EMU
Coach of the Year: Barb Bausch, GC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Kelly Smith | E&H | G | Angela Osborn | BC |
| G | Emily Mullet | EMU | G | Carrie McConnell | RC |
| C | Tara Carleton | R-MWC | F | Megan Barlow | GC |
| F | Arden Miller | GC | F | Renee Zando | R-MC |
| C | Amanda Kyger | BC | C | Crystal Barrett | RC |
2001
Player of the Year: Kelly Smith, E&H
Rookie of the Year: Sarah Crider, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Jean Willi, BC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Kelly Smith | E&H | G | Katrina Williams | RC |
| G | Emily Mullet | EMU | F/G | Arden Miller | GC |
| C | Crystal Barrett | RC | G | Amanda Osborn | BC |
| F | Jessica Mentz | W&L | G | Erin Beacham | GC |
| F/C | Sarah Hagood | BC | G | Angela Osborn | BC |
2002
Player of the Year: Jessica Mentz, W&L
Freshman of the Year: Courtney Hill, GC
Coach of the Year: Joy Scruggs, E&H
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Kelly Smith | E&H | G | Emily Mullet | EMU |
| G | Erin Beacham | GC | C | Megan Babst | W&L |
| G | Katrina Williams | RC | C | Crystal Barrett | RC |
| F | Jessica Mentz | W&L | F | Mandy Nichols | HU |
| F | Sarah Hagood | BC | G | Meredith Roberts | R-MC |
2003
Player of the Year: Katrina Williams, RC
Freshman of the Year: Megan Silva, RMC
Coach of the Year: Joy Scruggs, E&H
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G | Katrina Williams | RC | F | Courtney Hill | GC |
| G | Megan Silva | R-MC | F | Carrie Grandstaff | EMU |
| G | Brandi Cochran | HU | F | Stephanie Mathews | EMU |
| G | Danielle Moore | E&H | G | AJ Robertson | GC |
| G | Abby Pyzik | LC | G | Marie Bolton | BC |
2004
Player of the Year: Megan Silva, R-MC
Freshman of the Year: Katy Herr, BC
Coach of the Year: Jean Willi, BC
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: A.J. Robertson, GC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Emily Crider | R-MC | G | Brandi Cochran | HU |
| G | Carrie Grandstaff | EMU | G | Katy Herr | BC |
| G | Laura Ludholtz | EMU | F | Jennie Keichline | GC |
| G | Abby Pyzik | LC | F | Sarah Michaels | W&L |
| G | Megan Silva | R-MC | G | A.J. Robertson | GC |
2005
Player of the Year: Megan Silva, R-MC
Freshman of the Year: Erin Hanson, RC
Coach of the Year: Carroll LaHaye, R-MC
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Megan Silva, R-MC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Amanda Renalds | EMU | F | Jessica Hunsinger | W&L |
| G | Brandi Cochran | HU | F | Salem Shaffer | R-MC |
| G | Stephanie Mathews | EMU | F | Michelle Orton | R-MC |
| G | Courtney Hill | GC | G | Jennifer King | GC |
| G | Megan Silva | R-MC | G | Kate Childress | E&H |
2006
Player of the Year: Megan Silva, R-MC
Freshman of the Year: Kristine Ellis, GC
Coach of the Year: Stephany Dunmyer, VWC
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Marsha Kinder, BC
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| G/F | Erin Hanson | RC | F | Jessica Hunsinger | W&L |
| G | Jennifer King | GC | F | Meghan Stensrud | R-MWC |
| G | Marsha Kinder | BC | F | Michelle Orton | R-MC |
| G | Katy Herr | BC | F | Amanda Renalds | EMU |
| G | Megan Silva | R-MC | F | Heather Phillips | VWC |
2007
Player of the Year: Erin Hanson, Roanoke
Freshman of the Year: Molly Ariail, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Kevin Griffin, Eastern Mennonite
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Caroline Wesley, Lynchburg
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Erin Hanson | RC | C | Molly Ariail | R-MC |
| G | Katy Herr Lovell | BC | G/F | Tracey Croner | GC |
| F | Carolyn Riley | EMU | C | Jessica Hunsinger | W&L |
| F | Lindsay Riesbeck | R-MC | G/F | Kristen Krouchick | W&L |
| F | Nicole Thurston | VWC | G | Sara Rechnitzer | R-MWC |
| C | Caroline Wesley | LC | G | Shannon Scales | BC |
2008
Player of the Year: Molly Ariail, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: Jordan Burkholder, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Stephany Dunmyer, Virginia Wesleyan
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Amanda Hiltunen, Randolph-Macon
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| C | Molly Ariail | R-MC | F | Tracey Croner | GC |
| F | Brittany Dahn | LC | G | Kristina Darby | LC |
| F | Erin Hanson | RC | G | Ebony Denis | EMU |
| F | Heather Phillips | VWC | G | Amanda Hiltunen | R-MC |
| F | Lindsey Riesbeck | R-MC | G | Tonia Jones | VWC |
| F | Carolyn Riley | EMU | G | Sarah Petty | E&H |
2009
Player of the Year: Molly Ariail, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: Meghan Ingram, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Susan Dunagan, Roanoke
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Amanda Hiltunen, Randolph-Macon
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| C | Molly Ariail | R-MC | G | Jordan Burkholder | BC |
| F | Tracey Croner | GC | G | Meghan Ingram | W&L |
| G | Amanda Hiltunen | R-MC | C | Kylie Lucas | LC |
| G | Tonia Jones | VWC | G | Jaleesa Osborne | RC |
| G | Caitlyn Long | RC | G | Danielle Scott | EMU |
| F | Lindsay Riesbeck | R-MC | F | Brittany Snyder | EMU |
2010
Player of the Year: Molly Ariail, Randolph-Macon
Freshman of the Year: Jasmine Greene, Hollins
Coach of the Year: Susan Dunagan, Roanoke
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Maggie Davis, Virginia Wesleyan
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| C | Molly Ariail | R-MC | G | Meg Ingram | W&L |
| F | Becca Bolton | W&L | G | Tonia Jones | VWC |
| G | Jordan Burkholder | BC | G | Melissa Lewis | EMU |
| C | Jordan Gholson | RC | G | Katie Rechnitzer | RAND |
| G | Caitlyn Long | RC | G | Maggie Roy | R-MC |
| G | Jaleesa Osborne | RC | G | Ann Seufer | GC |
2011
Player of the Year: Jordan Burkholder, Bridgewater
Freshman of the Year: Kala Yoders, Eastern Mennonite
Coach of the Year: Jean Willi, Bridgewater
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Becca Bolton, Washington and Lee
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team |
| F | Kristen Blalock | VWC | F | Becca Bolton | W&L |
| F | Jordan Burkholder | BC | C | Jordan Gholson | RC |
| G | Meg Ingram | W&L | G | Jazlyn Gibbs | GC |
| C | Nicci Moats | RC | G | Jasmine Greene | HU |
| G | Jessica Mullen | BC | G | Danielle Rittenhouse | EMU |
| G | Maggie Roy | R-MC | C | Taylor Wieczorek | R-MC |
2012
Player of the Year: Gabby Oglesby, Guilford
Freshman of the Year: Sarah Seipp, Virginia Wesleyan
Coach of the Year: Stephany Dunmyer, Virginia Wesleyan
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Becca Bolton, Washington and Lee
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| F | Becca Bolton | W&L | G | Meg Ingram | W&L | G/F | Shannon Allan | LC |
| F | Gabby Oglesby | GC | C | Kristen Blalock | VWC | G/F | Paxton Gwin | RC |
| G | Sarah Seipp | E&H | G | Jazlyn Gibbs | GC | G | Jenny Logan | BC |
| C | Taylor Wieczorek | R-MC | G | Jasmine Greene | HU | G | Sarah Parsons | R-MC |
| G | Jessica Mullen | BC | G | Maggie Roy | R-MC | G | Stephanie Rheinheimer | EMU |
| F | Bianca Ygarza | EMU | F | Kala Yoders | EMU | G/F | Katy Wilson | W&L |
2013
Rookie of the Year: Katie Anderson, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Kevin Griffin, Eastern Mennonite
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Katy Wilson, Washington and Lee
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| F | Shannon Allan | LC | G | Brittany Atwater | GC | F | Katie Anderson | R-MC |
| F | Gabby Oglesby | GC | C | Morgan King | GC | G | Holly Chittenden | SU |
| G | Paxton Gwin | RC | G | Sarah Parsons | R-MC | F | Karina Farr | E&H |
| G | Jasmine Greene | HU | G | Sarah Seipp | VWC | G | Brittany Glasco | VWC |
| G | Jessica Mullen | BC | F | Katy Wilson | W&L | G | Holly Morgan | BC |
| F | Bianca Ygarza | EMU | F | Shakeerah Sykes | EMU | F | Lauren Penley | LC |
2014
Player of the Year: Paxton Gwin, Roanoke
Rookie of the Year: Heather Cantrell, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Kevin Griffin, Eastern Mennonite
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Kristie Langley, Emory & Henry
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| F | Shannon Allan | LC | F | Katie Anderson | R-MC | G | Keyla Baltimore | EMU |
| G | Brittany Glasco | VWC | G | Imani Heggins | SU | G | Abigail Bullins | RAND |
| G | Paxton Gwin | RC | F | Morgan King | GC | F | Chaney Forbush | LC |
| G | Taylor Huber | R-MC | G | Holly Morgan | BC | F | Laurel Hankins | RC |
| F | Gabby Oglesby | GC | G | Sarah Parsons | R-MC | F | Shakeerah Sykes | EMU |
| F | Bianca Ygarza | EMU | F | Jess Rheinheimer | EMU | F | Chanci Wright | HU |
2015
Player of the Year: Jess Rheinheimer, Eastern Mennonite
Rookie of the Year: Chloe Harris, Emory & Henry
Coach of the Year: Kevin Griffin, Eastern Mennonite
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Jess Rheinheimer, Eastern Mennonite
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| F | Shannon Allan | LC | F | Cary Beahm | RC | G | Abigail Bullins | RAND |
| F | Katie Anderson | R-MC | G | Jackie Clifford | W&L | G | Cassidy Burkholder | BC |
| G | Brittany Glasco | VWC | G | Brittany Drew | GC | F | Karina Farr | E&H |
| G | Sarah Parsons | R-MC | F | Chaney Forbush | LC | G | Charmaine Hairston | LC |
| F | Jess Rheinheimer | EMU | G | Hannah Livermon | R-MC | G | Megan Jacoby | E&H |
| F | Shakeerah Sykes | EMU | F | Anais Weatherly | GC | G | Andrea Paphites | VWC |
2016
Player of the Year: Jess Rheinheimer, Sr., Forward, Eastern Mennonite
Rookie of the Year: Taylor Blevins, Fr., Guard, Emory & Henry
Coach of the Year: Stephanie Flamini, Guilford
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Jess Rheinheimer, Eastern Mennonite
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| F | Katie Anderson | R-MC | G | Taylor Blevins | E&H | G | Sarah Coronel | LC |
| F | Cary Beahm | RC | G | Jackie Clifford | W&L | F | Karina Farr | E&H |
| G | Cassidy Burkholder | BC | G | Sammi Goldsmith | LC | G | Kelly Jones | VWC |
| F | Chaney Forbush | LC | G | Jayla Harris | VWC | F | Ailyn Kelly | W&L |
| F | Jess Rheinheimer | EMU | G | Megan Jacoby | E&H | G | Jessica Lam | BC |
| F | Anais Weatherly | GC | G | Hannah Livermon |
R-MC |
F | Lauren Ramsey | GC |
2017
Player of the Year: Jessica Lam, Sr., G., Bridgewater
Rookie of the Year: Kelly Williams, Fr., C., Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Abby Pyzik Smith, Lynchburg
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Cary Beahm, Sr., F., Roanoke
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| G | Charmaine Hairston | LC | F | Cary Beahm | RC | C | Jonae Guest | EMU |
| G | Jayla Harris | VWC | F | Taylor Blevins | E&H | F | Amber Lee | R-MC |
| G | Jessica Lam | BC | G | Megan Jacoby | E&H | C | Kaitlyn Lehan | BC |
| G | Emily Perszyk | W&L | F | Caroline Naumann | LC | G | Lauren Ramsey | GC |
| F | Anais Weatherly | GC | G | Myneshia Walker | EMU | G | Chloe Roach | EMU |
| C | Kelly Williams | R-MC | F | Heaven Walters |
GC |
F | Molly Shephard | LC |
2018
Player of the Year: Kelly Williams, So., C, Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Katie Popp, Fr., G, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Anne Crutchfield, Emory & Henry
Farm Bureau/ODAC Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Emily Perszyk, Sr., G, Washington and Lee
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| F | Taylor Blevins | E&H | G | Olivia DeFrancesco | LC | G/F | Brittany Afolabi-Brown | LC |
| G | Jayla Harris | VWU | F | Sydney McKinney | E&H | G | Katie Popp | W&L |
| F | Caroline Naumann | LC | G | Briana Moore | BC | G | Ashley Stone | SU |
| G | Emily Perszyk | W&L | F | Molly Shephard | LC | G | Myneshia Walker | EMU |
| G | Lauren Ramsey | GC | F | Jordan Sondrol | SU | F | Jess Washington | EMU |
| C | Kelly Williams | R-MC | F | Miracle Walters |
GC |
F | Charlotte Woods | R-MC |
2019
Player of the Year: Jayla Harris, Sr., G, Virginia Wesleyan
Defensive Player of the Year: Erin Hughes, So., G, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Stephanie Flamini, Guilford
Rookie of the Year: Lindsay Gauldin, Fy., F, Guilford
Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Briana Moore, Sr., G, Bridgewater
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| F | Taylor Blevins | E&H | F | Lindsay Gauldin | GC | G | Amanda Gerni | VWU |
| G | Jayla Harris | VWU | F | Rebecca Harvey | BC | G | Whitney Hopson | RC |
| G | Taylor Casey | W&L | G | Erin Hughes | W&L | G | Maggie Quarles | LYN |
| G | Brianna Moore | BC | F | Sydney McKinney | E&H | F | Andy Smithey | W&L |
| F | Molly Shephard | LYN | F | Michal Ross | R-MC | F | Ashley Stone | SU |
| F | Miracle Walters | GC | F | Charlotte Woods |
R-MC |
F | Peyton Williams | E&H |
2020
Player of the Year: Kelly Williams, Sr., C, Randolph-Macon
Co-Defensive Player of the Year: Madison Baum, Jr., G, Bridgewater
Co-Defensive Player of the Year: Peyton Williams, Sr., G, Emory & Henry
Coach of the Year: Jaclyn Dickens, Emory & Henry
Rookie of the Year: Abby Oguich, So., Lynchburg
Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Kelly Williams, Sr., C, Randolph-Macon
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| G | Ahlia Moone | BC | F | Kara Stafford | E&H | G | Madison Baumn | BC |
| F | Sydney McKinney | E&H | F | Miracle Waters | GC | F | Erin Green | LYN |
| G | Peyton Williams | E&H | G | Kayla Surles | HU | F | Abby Oguich | LYN |
| C | Kelly Williams | R-MC | F | Michal Ross | R-MC | F | Charlotte Woods | R-MC |
| F | Jordan Sondrol | SU | G | Taylor Casey | W&L | G | Kristina Harrel | RC |
| G | Erin Hughes | W&L | F | Andy Smithey |
W&L |
G | Megan Horn | W&L |
2021
Player of the Year: Abby Oguich, Jr., F, Lynchburg
Defensive Player of the Year: Whitney Hopson, Jr., G, Roanoke
Coach of the Year: Katie Crump, Lynchburg
Rookie of the Year: Kylie Stark, Fy., G, Randolph
Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Olivia Weinel, Jr., F, Shenandoah
| All-ODAC Team | ||||||||
| G | Jada Gross | BC | F | Abby Oguich | LYN | G | Whitney Hopson | RC |
| G | Ahlia Moone | BC | G | Maggie Quarles | LYN | F | Sarah Sondrol | SU |
| G | Kylea Cooper | E&H | G | Kylie Stark | RAND | G | Sierra St. Cyr | SU |
| C | Alexis Hoopers | E&H | G | Becca Arrington | R-MC | G | S'Zahria Jones | VWU |
| G | Kayla Cabiness | FC | G/F | Renee Alquiza | RC | G | Megan Horn | W&L |
| G | Lizzie Davis | LYN | G | Kristina Harrel | RC | G | Erin Hughes | W&L |
| *The ODAC men's basketball coaches named one All-ODAC Team for the 2021 spring season due to frequency of play during the COVID-19 pandemic | ||||||||
2022
Player of the Year: Megan Horn, Sr., G, Washington and Lee
Defensive Player of the Year: Sierra St. Cyr, Sr., G, Shenandoah
Coach of the Year: Christine Clancy, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Teniya Crenshaw-Patterson, Fy., G, Randolph
Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Lizzie Davis, Sr., G, Lynchburg
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| G | Lindsay Gauldin | GC | G | Kayla Surles | HU | F | Jaden Alsbery | BC |
| G | Kylie Stark | RAND | G | Lizzie Davis | LYN | F | Erika Nettles | BC |
| F | Catherine Kagey | R-MC | G | Teniyah Crenshaw-Patterson | RAND | F | Erin Green | LYN |
| F | Renee Alquiza | RC | G | Becca Anthony | R-MC | C | Kate Kolb | LYN |
| F | Olivia Weinel | SU | G | Kristina Harrel | RC | G | Sierra St. Cyr | SU |
| G | Megan Horn | W&L | G | Jordan Diehl | W&L | G | Hanna Malik | W&L |
2023
Player of the Year: Lindsay Gauldin, Gr., F, Guilford
Defensive Player of the Year: Mary Schleusner, Fy., F, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Christine Clancy, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Mary Schleusner, Fy., F, Washington and Lee
Va. Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete: Catherine Kagey, Jr., G/F, Randolph-Macon
| Pos. | First Team | Team | Pos. | Second Team | Team | Pos. | Third Team | Team |
| F | Lindsay Gauldin | GC | P | Jaden Alsberry | BC | P | Erika Nettles | BC |
| G | Kylie Stark | RAND | G | Riley Corcoran | BC | G | Maddie Nimmo | LYN |
| F | Catherine Kagey | R-MC | G/F | Mya Hamlet | EMU | G | Teniyah Crenshaw-Patterson | RAND |
| G | Terese Greene | SU | F | Anna Giannopoulou | GC | G | Cheridan Hatfield | R-MC |
| G | Hanna Malik | W&L | F | Rose Sande | RC | F | Shawnise Campbell | SU |
| F | Mary Schleusner | W&L | G | Madisen Kimble | SU | F | Grace O'Connor | W&L |