Each year the conference tournament is named the conference champion. Beginning in 1999, the ODAC champion received an automatic bid into the NCAA Tournament bracket. Only once has a conference tournament not been completed and a conference champion determined through the coaches committee (regular season winner).

1977
Lynchburg (10-2, 22-6)
defeated Randolph-Macon 4-3

1978
Bridgewater (8-4, 17-7)
defeated Randolph-Macon 5-2

1979
Randolph-Macon (9-3, 16-6)
defeated Bridgewater 11-7

1980
Lynchburg (12-0, 22-4-1)
*By a vote of the league's head baseball coaches under a provision in the conference rules, LC was declrared team champion when the championship tournament was cancelled due to inclement weather and poor field conditions.

1981
Lynchburg (13-0, 23-5)
defeated Bridgewater 12-3

1982
Lynchburg (12-2, 27-6)
defeated Hampden-Sydney 6-1

1983
Lynchburg (12-0, 25-4)
defeated Eastern Mennonite 20-0

1984
Lynchburg (12-0, 25-4)
defeated Washington and Lee 4-1

1985
Bridgewater (8-6, 18-11)
defeated Randolph-Macon 6-4

1986
Bridgewater (12-2, 23-7)
defeated Randolph-Macon 9-2

1987
Randolph-Macon (12-0, 20-3-1)
defeated Bridgewater 11-4

1988
Bridgewater (13-1, 25-8)
defeated Lynchburg 9-1

1989
Hampden-Sydney (9-3, 17-5)
defeated Lynchburg 8-4

1990
Lynchburg (8-4, 23-6)
defeated Hampden-Sydney 18-6

1991
Bridgewater (9-5, 18-13)
defeated Hampden-Sydney 6-3

1992
Guilford (12-3, 26-12-1)
defeated Lynchburg 4-1

1993
Guilford (12-4, 30-12)
defeated Hampden-Sydney 12-10

1994
Bridgewater (11-5, 25-9)
defeated Lynchburg 22-9

1995
Bridgewater (14-2, 25-10)
defeated Lynchburg 10-4

1996
Bridgewater (16-0, 27-8)
defeated Lynchburg 14-6

1997
Virginia Wesleyan (14-2, 31-12)
defeated Bridgewater 15-5

1998
Virginia Wesleyan (12-4, 22-19)
defeated Guilford 5-4

1999
Bridgewater (11-5, 26-19)
defeated Washington and Lee 13-2

2000
Virginia Wesleyan (14-2, 32-10)
defeated Bridgewater 8-7 (12 innings)

2001
Bridgewater (13-3, 26-16)
defeated Virginia Wesleyan 6-5 (10 innings)

2002
Bridgewater (13-2-1, 26-18-1)
defeated Guilford, 8-5

2003
Virginia Wesleyan (17-1, 34-9)
defeated Washington and Lee, 11-3

2004
Virginia Wesleyan 
defeated Washington and Lee, 12-8

2005
Hampden-Sydney 
defeated Lynchburg, 4-3

2006
Virginia Wesleyan
defeated Bridgewater, 7-6

2007
Bridgewater
defeated Hampden-Sydney, 7-0

2008
Randolph-Macon
defeated Virginia Wesleyan, 4-2

2009
Washington and Lee
defeated Virginia Wesleyan, 10-6

2010
Bridgewater
defeated Lynchburg, 9-5

2011
Randolph-Macon
defeated Bridgewater, 6-2

2012
Lynchburg
defeated Bridgewater, 2-1

2013
Randolph-Macon
defeated Bridgewater, 6-2

2014
Bridgewater
defeated Shenandoah, 6-5

2015
Shenandoah
defeated Virginia Wesleyan, 4-2

2016
Randolph-Macon
defeated Hampden-Sydney, 6-5

2017
Roanoke
defeated Washington and Lee, 4-3

2018
Shenandoah
defeated Roanoke, 8-4

2019
Shenandoah
defeated Randolph-Macon, 5-4

2020
*2020 spring sports were suspended indefinitely and championships were not conducted due to COVID-19.

2021
Lynchburg
defeated Shenandoah, 2-1 (5-12, 11-5, 9-8)

2022
Shenandoah
defeated Roanoke, 13-0

2023
Lynchburg
defeated Shenandoah, 11-9

Total Number of Championships: