WEEK 1: SEPTEMBER 6, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Caleb Jennings, RB, Emory & Henry
  Defensive Player of the Week: Darius Burrus, CB, Bridgewater

WEEK 2: SEPTEMBER 13, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Sean Cavanaugh, WR, Hampden-Sydney
  Defensive Player of the Week: Evin O'Sullivan, LB, Emory & Henry

WEEK 3: SEPTEMBER 20, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Kirk Rohle, RB, Hampden-Sydney
  Defensive Player of the Week: Will Riggenbach, DL, Hampden-Sydney

WEEK 4: SEPTEMBER 27, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Kirk Rohle, RB, Hampden-Sydney
  Defensive Player of the Week: Bill Doody, DB, Hampden-Sydney

WEEK 5: OCTOBER 4, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Earl Peoples, WR, Randolph-Macon
  Defensive Player of the Week: Jordan Nelson, CB, Guilford

WEEK 6: OCTOBER 11, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Jonathan Clemo, RB, Washington and Lee
  Defensive Player of the Week: Trevor Ikwild, LB, Hampden-Sydney

WEEK 7: OCTOBER 18, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Thomas Tate, RB, Bridgewater
  Defensive Player of the Week: Joe Pricone, DE, Randolph-Macon

WEEK 8: OCTOBER 25, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Thomas Tate, RB, Bridgewater
  Defensive Player of the Week: Michael Ware, DB, Hampden-Sydney

WEEK 9: NOVEMBER 1, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Tyler Beiler, WR, Bridgewater
  Defensive Player of the Week: Richie Paul, LB, Guilford

WEEK 10: NOVEMBER 8, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Corey Sedlar, QB, Hampden-Sydney
  Defensive Player of the Week: Jordan Nelson, DB, Guilford

WEEK 11: NOVEMBER 15, 2009
  Offensive Player of the Week: Caleb Jennings, RB, Emory & Henry
  Defensive Player of the Week: Will Riggenbach, DL, Hampden-Sydney