All-Time Football All-Conference Teams
1976
Player of the Year: Tony Perry, WR, W&L
Coach of the Year: Ted Keller, R-MC
| All-ODAC First Team | |||||
| OL | Bob Wilson | H-SC | DL | Scott Crow | R-MC |
|
|
Bill Davis | R-MC |
|
Jack Reeves | W&L |
|
|
Chris Mawdsley | E&H | DE | Scott Boone | R-MC |
|
|
Steve DiBiagio | W&L |
|
Keith Sturgill | E&H |
|
|
Phil Haley | H-SC | LB | Steven Baril | H-SC |
| WR | Ben Newell | H-SC |
|
John Monroe | R-MC |
|
|
Jeff Hutchison | R-MC |
|
John Holland | BC |
|
|
Ron Mabry | E&H | DB | David Hardie | H-SC |
| TE | Tony Perry | W&L |
|
Barry Banton | R-MC |
| RB | Mike Woolfolk | R-MC |
|
Jack Norberg | W&L |
|
|
Jim Ferguson | H-SC |
|
Mark Harman | R-MC |
| QB | Mike Roberts | E&H | SP | Bruce Kirk | R-MC |
1977
Player of the Year: Jim Ferguson, RB, H-SC
Coach of the Year: Stokeley Fulton, H-SC
| All-ODAC First Team | |||||
| OL | Bob Wilson | H-SC | DL | Tim Smith | H-SC |
|
|
Bill Davis | R-MC |
|
Keith Sweaney | R-MC |
|
|
Mark Duncan | W&L | DE | Keith Sturgill | E&H |
|
|
Keith Love | H-SC |
|
Noel Stone | H-SC |
|
|
Jerry Beitman | R-MC | LB | Jeff Slatcoff | W&L |
| WR | Ben Newell | H-SC |
|
Brent Cunningham | R-MC |
|
|
Art Andrey | BC |
|
John Holland | BC |
| TE | Mike Snow | E&H | DB | Chip Hill | E&H |
| RB | Jim Ferguson | H-SC |
|
Mike Harcum | H-SC |
|
|
Mike Woolfolk | R-MC |
|
Bill Koepsel | R-MC |
| QB | Dale Marks | H-SC |
|
Don Crossley | W&L |
|
|
|
|
SP | Mike Adkins | H-SC |
1978
Player of the Year: Carl Folcik, LB, W&L
Coach of the Year: Ted Keller, R-MC
| All-ODAC First Team | |||||
| C | Wally Moore | HS | DL | Joe Freeland | BC |
| OG | Scott Smith | W&L |
|
Tim Smith | H-SC |
|
|
Brian Sweaney | R-MC |
|
Ricky Eades | R-MC |
| OT | Steve Hurley | E&H | DE | Elliott Bondurant | H-SC |
|
|
George Berry | W&L |
|
Chip King | R-MC |
| TE | Blair Webb | R-MC | LB | Carl Folcik | W&L |
| WR | John Wilson | E&H |
|
Jeff Stone | E&H |
|
|
Richard Wiles | W&L | DB | Tim Maxa | H-SC |
| RB | Mike Woolfolk | R-MC |
|
Mark Harman | R-MC |
|
|
Jim Ferguson | H-SC |
|
Chip Hill | E&H |
| QB | Marty Browder | E&H |
|
Don Crossley | W&L |
|
|
|
|
SP | Jeff Stone | E&H |
1979
Co-Player of the Year: Ricky Eades, DT, R-MC
Co-Player of the Year: Tim Smith, DT, H-SC
Coach of the Year: Ted Keller, R-MC
| All-ODAC First Team | |||||
| C | Paul Emerick | H-SC | DT | Tim Smith | H-SC |
| OG | Scott Smith | W&L |
|
Ricky Eades | R-MC |
|
|
Todd Collier | R-MC | DE | Chip King | R-MC |
| OT | Chip Nunley | W&L |
|
Steve Irvin | E&H |
|
|
Bob Brinkley | R-MC | NG | Gerald Hoffman | BC |
| TE | Tripp Billingsley | R-MC | LB | Tom Garner | H-SC |
| WR | Scott Moorhead | H-SC |
|
Ben Madison | R-MC |
|
|
John Dwyer | BC | DB | Bill Koepsel | R-MC |
| RB | Stew Atkinson | W&L |
|
Tim Maxa | H-SC |
|
|
Larry Lane | R-MC |
|
Don Glass | E&H |
| QB | Duane Harrison | BC |
|
Tony Davenport | BC |
|
|
|
|
SP | Duane Harrison | BC |
1980
Player of the Year: Ricky Eades, DL, R-MC
Coach of the Year: John Spencer, BC
| All-ODAC First Team | |||||
| C | Jeff McCurry | BC | DL | Mike Pressler | W&L |
| OG | Barry Bailey | E&H |
|
Larry Wright | MC |
|
|
Todd Collier | R-MC |
|
Ricky Eades | R-MC |
| OT | Chip Nunley | W&L | DG | Greg White | MC |
|
|
Howard Hoyt | E&H | LB | Ben Madison | R-MC |
| TE | Mike Fogarty | W&L |
|
John Cole | BC |
| WR | Mike Avellino | MC | DB | Gerald Benjamin | BC |
|
|
Scott Moorhead | H-SC |
|
Tom Thalman | H-SC |
| RB | Kevin Skipper | MC |
|
Skip Goree | R-MC |
|
|
Gary Richins | R-MC | Chris Leiser | W&L | |
| QB | Duane Harrison | BC |
|
David Blair | E&H |
| K | Clif Armstrong | R-MC | P | Duane Harrison | BC |
1981
Player of the Year: Chris Cavalline, RB, W&L
Coach of the Year: Gary Fallon, W&L
| All-ODAC First Team | |||||
| OL | Andy Foley | W&L | DE | David Heppner | H-SC |
|
|
Glenn Kirschner | W&L |
|
Bob Glascock | BC |
|
|
Doug Knight | MC | DL | Alex Albert | MC |
|
|
Phil Colclough | H-SC |
|
Mike MacNevin | R-MC |
|
|
Jim Flanigan | R-MC |
|
Mike Pressler | W&L |
| TE | Mike Fogarty | W&L | LB | Ed Belfi | MC |
| WR | Stevie Allen | E&H |
|
Rob Stanley | R-MC |
|
|
Gene Wheatley | MC | DB | Barry Thompson | W&L |
| RB | Chris Cavalline | W&L |
|
Tom Thalman | H-SC |
|
|
Tim Jones | H-SC |
|
Bob McQuade | MC |
| QB | Al Paradise | W&L |
|
Mike Keating | E&H |
| K | Bill Devine | W&L | P | Paul Fozo | H-SC |
1982
Player of the Year: Hiter Harris, K, H-SC
Coach of the Year: Stokeley Fulton, H-SC
| C | Glenn Kirschner | W&L | DE | Ken Manganiello | W&L |
| OL | Andy Foley | W&L |
|
Chip Anderson | R-MC |
|
|
Tony Volkadov | MC |
|
Frank Wheeler | H-SC |
|
|
Pete Popeck | R-MC | DL | Doug Parsons | H-SC |
|
|
Doug Knight | MC |
|
Rob McMillen | E&H |
| TE | Steve Larus | E&H |
|
John Cockfield | MC |
| WR | Gene Wheatley | MC |
|
Carlos Wood | BC |
|
|
Jeff Bonadies | BC | LB | Ray Carneal | R-MC |
| RB | Chris Cavalline | W&L |
|
David Allen | H-SC |
|
|
Mike Surrency | MC | DB | Phil Suazo | H-SC |
| QB | Andrew Tate | R-MC |
|
Bob McQuade | MC |
| K | Hiter Harris | H-SC |
|
Jay Pitts | R-MC |
|
|
|
|
|
Hal Duff | BC |
|
|
|
|
P | Barry Whitehead | MC |
1983
Player of the Year: Ralph Fucillo, DL, CUA
Coach of the Year: Stokeley Fulton, H-SC
| C | Glenn Kirschner | W&L | DL | Jeff Carrington | R-MC |
| OL | Gus Paulette | H-SC |
|
Ralph Fucillo | CUA |
|
|
Danny Seal | W&L |
|
Rob McMillen | E&H |
|
|
Doug Seay | R-MC |
|
Doug Parsons | H-SC |
|
|
Tony Volkadov | MC |
|
Carlos Wood | BC |
| TE | Ian Banwell | W&L | LB | David Allen | H-SC |
| WR | Steve Allen | E&H |
|
John Cole | W&L |
|
|
John Hildreth | CUA | DB | Paul Anagnostis | MC |
| RB | Gene Girard | W&L |
|
Wayne Hall | E&H |
|
|
Alan Wright | R-MC |
|
Jay Pitts | R-MC |
| QB | Tony Gallis | CUA |
|
Phil Suazo | H-SC |
| K | Brad Cary | H-SC | P | T.J. Murray | CUA |
1984
Player of the Year: Cody Dearing, QB, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Jim Blackburn, R-MC
| C | Harry Golliday | W&L | DL | Tom Shaw | R-MC |
| OL | Pat Kane | H-SC |
|
Rob McMillen | E&H |
|
|
Glen Spangler | E&H |
|
Mike Sharp | H-SC |
|
|
Ed Victor | R-MC |
|
Gary Wheeler | H-SC |
|
|
Steve Faggert | R-MC |
|
Troy Chandler | E&H |
| TE | Steve Larus | E&H | LB | David Allen | H-SC |
| WR | Keith Gilliam | R-MC |
|
Tony Francis | R-MC |
|
|
Steve Allen | E&H | DB | Phil Suazo | H-SC |
| RB | Sandy Rogers | E&H |
|
Paul Anaganostic | MC |
|
|
David Kelly | H-SC |
|
Lloyd Hicks | R-MC |
| QB | Cody Dearing | R-MC |
|
Mike Lindsay | E&H |
| K | James White | W&L | P | Brian Brotzman | H-SC |
1985
Player of the Year: Kevin Weaver, RB, W&L
Coach of the Year: Lou Wacker, E&H
| OL | Jeff Keys | E&H | DL | Troy Chandler | E&H |
|
|
Glenn Spangler | E&H |
|
Mark Saunders | BC |
|
|
Brett Bennet | H-SC |
|
Rob McMillen | E&H |
|
|
Scott Fiedler | R-MC |
|
Mike Sharp | H-SC |
|
|
John Packett | W&L |
|
Herbie Hope | R-MC |
| WR | Keith Gilliam | R-MC | LB | David Davis | E&H |
|
|
Chuck Arington | H-SC |
|
Todd Rogers | R-MC |
| TE | Chris Johannsen | MC | DB | Chip Umberger | H-SC |
| RB | Kevin Weaver | W&L |
|
Joey Owens | R-MC |
|
|
Sandy Rogers | E&H |
|
Tim Janyska | W&L |
| QB | Tim Landis | R-MC |
|
Keith Furr | E&H |
| K | Jack Ginn | E&H | P | Shaun Miller | R-MC |
1986
Player of the Year: Sandy Rogers, RB, E&H
Coach of the Year: Lou Wacker, E&H
| C | Scott Vinson | H-SC | K | Jimmy Hondroulis | H-SC |
| OL | Pat Kane | H-SC | DL | Mark Saunders | BC |
|
|
Steve Dean | E&H |
|
Troy Chandler | E&H |
|
|
John Packett | W&L |
|
H.O. Lyne | E&H |
|
|
Aaron Boston | R-MC |
|
D. Lauderdale | MC |
| TE | Jon Waite | H-SC | LB | David Kassnove | E&H |
| WR | Randy Brown | W&L |
|
Todd Rogers | R-MC |
|
|
Chris Johannsen | MC | DB | Keith Furr | E&H |
| RB | Sandy Rogers | E&H |
|
Chip Umberger | H-SC |
|
|
David Kelly | H-SC |
|
Jack Barber | H-SC |
|
|
Remon Smith | R-MC |
|
Mike Walsh | MC |
| QB | Gary Collier | E&H |
|
|
|
1987
Player of the Year: Gary Collier, QB, E&H
Coach of the Year: Joe Bush, H-SC
| C | Scott Vinson | H-SC | K | Jake Darrell | BC |
| OL | Brett Bennett | H-SC | DL | Mark Saunders | R-MC |
|
|
Taylor Lyne | E&H |
|
Chris Kirchenheiter | R-MC |
|
|
Aaron Boston | R-MC |
|
Jim Johnson | W&L |
|
|
Leroy Blow | R-MC | DE | Barry Landis | R-MC |
| TE | F.T. Johnson | E&H |
|
Jeff Reichert | MC |
| WR | Paul Overbay | E&H | LB | Tom Skeen | W&L |
|
|
Hugh Finkelstein | W&L |
|
Stacey Whitt | E&H |
| RB | Remon Smith | R-MC | DB | John Cox | BC |
|
|
Anthony Lawrence | BC |
|
Mike Stup | E&H |
| QB | Gary Collier | E&H |
|
Jack Barber | H-SC |
| P | Jason Harbison | MC |
|
Rob Howard | R-MC |
1988
Player of the Year: Anthony Lawrence, RB, BC
Coach of the Year: Gary Fallon, W&L
| OL | T.C. Wilson | H-SC | K | Carter Quayle | W&L |
|
|
John Willson | E&H | DL | Steve Bowman | E&H |
|
|
Rip West | H-SC |
|
Jim Johnson | W&L |
|
|
Aaron Boston | R-MC |
|
Chris Higgs | H-SC |
|
|
B.I. Salyers | E&H | DE | Greg Dofflemeyer | BC |
| TE | Paul Overbay | E&H |
|
Jody Kane | R-MC |
| WR | Stephen Waskey | H-SC | LB | Jeff Whiten | BC |
|
|
John Lakey | E&H |
|
Tom Skeen | W&L |
| RB | Anthony Lawrence | BC | DB | Doug Reavis | E&H |
|
|
Rodney Beville | E&H |
|
Jack Barber | H-SC |
| QB | Dan Laramore | H-SC |
|
Rob Howard | R-MC |
| P | Brian Puckett | BC |
|
Deon Johnson | BC |
1989
Player of the Year: Jody Kane, DE, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Jim Blackburg, R-MC
| C | T.C. Wilson | H-SC | DL | Jason Grooms | E&H |
| OL | B.I. Salyers | E&H |
|
Chris Higgs | H-SC |
|
|
Scott Brooks | H-SC |
|
Mike Fitzmeyer | BC |
|
|
John Willson | E&H | DE | Jody Kane | R-MC |
|
|
Rob Roberton | W&L |
|
Steve Sallee | E&H |
| TE | Bob Martin | W&L | LB | Jeff Whiten | BC |
| WR | Craig Irons | W&L |
|
Mike Pack | W&L |
|
|
Stephen Waskey | H-SC | DB | Doug Reavis | E&H |
| RB | Anthony Lawrence | BC |
|
Deon Johnson | BC |
|
|
Len Armstrong | H-SC |
|
Trip McLaughlin | H-SC |
| QB | Phillip Sampson | W&L |
|
Bobby Rimmer | W&L |
| K | Mark Palmgren | R-MC | P | Brian Puckett | BC |
1990
Player of the Year: B.I. Salyers, OL, E&H
Coach of the Year: Joe Bush, H-SC
| C | Frank Sudell | W&L | DL | Brad Bowman |
|
| OL | Wayne Short | BC |
|
Greg Hatfield | H-SC |
|
|
B.I. Salyers | E&H |
|
Tony Lipford | R-MC |
|
|
Bobby Hinkle | H-SC | DE | Mike Fitzmeyer | BC |
|
|
Brian Bufton | R-MC |
|
Marvin Thompson | R-MC |
| TE | John Jewell | H-SC | LB | Jonathan Greer | BC |
| WR | Craig Irons | W&L |
|
Rob Whitfield | R-MC |
|
|
Cary Perkins | E&H | DB | Chris Dodson | BC |
| RB | Scotty Verran | E&H |
|
Steve Munsey | E&H |
|
|
Len Armstrong | H-SC |
|
Shawn Spear | R-MC |
| QB | Pat Walker | E&H |
|
Brad Miller | W&L |
| K | David Brickhill | H-SC | P | Dexter Hurt | R-MC |
1991
Player of the Year: Calvin Hunter, QB, GC
Coach of the Year: Mike Ketchum, GC
| C | Chris Grefe | BC | DL | Jason Grooms | E&H |
| OL | Wayne Short | BC |
|
Rodney Alexander | GC |
|
|
Jim Brooks | E&H |
|
Greg Hatfield | R-MC |
|
|
Pat Buchanan | E&H | DE | Scott Pruner | E&H |
|
|
Jeff Crowder | R-MC |
|
Shannon Manire | GC |
| TE | John VaValle | H-SC | LB | Jonathan Greer | BC |
| WR | Jay Hicks | H-SC |
|
Darren Reed | E&H |
|
|
Steve Dodd | R-MC | DB | Tim Runion | BC |
| RB | Cetric Gayles | H-SC |
|
Wes Pilgram | E&H |
|
|
Billy Allen | E&H |
|
Clarence Inscore | GC |
| QB | Calvin Hunter | GC |
|
Harry Murn | R-MC |
| K | Mike Duffy | R-MC | P | Bob Ehret | W&L |
1992
Player of the Year: Cary Perkins, QB, E&H
Coach of the Year: Gary Fallon, W&L
| C | Reid Ebert | E&H | DL | Greg Hatfield | H-SC |
| OL | Pat Buchanan | E&H |
|
Mike Powell | E&H |
|
|
Eric Dye | H-SC |
|
Mike Keyoe | R-MC |
|
|
John Surface | W&L | DE | Scott Pruner | E&H |
|
|
Drew Bishop | E&H |
|
Adam Dowe | E&H |
| TE | John Ely | E&H | LB | Mike Stansbury | E&H |
| WR | Garry Carter | R-MC |
|
Rob Davenport | GC |
|
|
William Propst | W&L | DB | Harry Murn | R-MC |
| RB | Chad Duncan | H-SC |
|
Curtis Turner | H-SC |
|
|
Kerrell Bryant | R-MC |
|
Scott Cox | E&H |
| QB | Cary Perkins | E&H |
|
William Prince | BC |
| K | Andrew Thomas | W&L | P | Bob Ehret | W&L |
1993
Player of the Year: Ronnie Howard, RB, BC
Coach of the Year: Joe Riccio, R-MC
| C | Reid Ebert | E&H | DL | Robert Hull | W&H |
| OL | Rex Carter | E&H |
|
Mike Powell | E&H |
|
|
Bryan Garland | GC |
|
Chad Wheeling | H-SC |
|
|
John Surface | W&L | DE | Scott McFalls | H-SC |
|
|
Matt Kerry | H-SC |
|
Adam Dowe | E&H |
| TE | John Ely | E&H | LB | Darren Reed | E&H |
| WR | Garry Carter | R-MC |
|
Max Appleby | GC |
|
|
Todd Woodall | E&H | DB | Ricky Webb | E&H |
| RB | Ronnie Howard | BC |
|
Dwayne Elmore | R-MC |
|
|
Jeff Hatch | GC |
|
Avery Farmer | R-MC |
| QB | Andy Bush | R-MC |
|
Drew Baker | GC |
| K | Tony Labrador | R-MC | P | Mark Middleton | E&H |
1994
Player of the Year: David Heggie, RB, GC
Coach of the Year: Lou Wacker, E&H
| C | Brian Taylor | H-SC | DL | Robert Hull | W&L |
| OL | T. Overstreet | R-MC |
|
Paul Lee | R-MC |
|
|
Kevin Rogers | E&H |
|
Chad Wheeling | H-SC |
|
|
Bryan Garland | GC | DE | Marcel Howard | R-MC |
|
|
Matt Kerry | H-SC |
|
Steve Godsey | E&H |
| TE | Jody Cohen | H-SC | LB | Darren Reed | E&H |
| WR | Aaron Fuller | E&H |
|
Tim Armoska | R-MC |
|
|
Junior Lord | GC | DB | Jon Wagner | W&L |
|
|
William Propst | W&L |
|
Evan Jones | R-MC |
| RB | David Heggie | GC |
|
Avery Farmer | R-MC |
|
|
Robert Thompson | H-SC |
|
Pat Tully | GC |
| QB | Andy Bush | R-MC | P | Mark Middleton | E&H |
| K | Wade Vidal | E&H |
|
|
|
1995
Player of the Year: Robert Hull, DT, W&L
Coach of the Year: Lou Wacker, E&H
| C | Andy Bowers | E&H | DL | Robert Hull | W&L |
| OL | Kevin Edwards | E&H |
|
Adam Mizer | BC |
|
|
Kevin Rogers | E&H |
|
Jamie Harless | E&H |
|
|
Robert Turner | W&L | DE | Mike Fleming | R-MC |
|
|
Lewis Pollard | R-MC |
|
Steve Godsey | E&H |
| TE | Derek Jones | E&H | LB | Jeff Anderson | H-SC |
| WR | Chris Turner | E&H |
|
Tim Armoska | R-MC |
|
|
Junior Lord | GC | DB | Brent Rusnak | H-SC |
| RB | David Heggie | GC |
|
Evan Jones | R-MC |
|
|
J.D. Davis | E&H |
|
Stuart Hogue | W&L |
| QB | Brooks Fischer | W&L |
|
Thomas Nelson | E&H |
| K | Tony Labrador | R-MC | P | David Heggie | GC |
1996
Player of the Year: Tim Armoska, LB, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Frank Miriello, W&L
| C | Chris Moore | R-MC | DL | Burt Torrence | E&H |
| OL | Jody Carter | E&H |
|
Adam Mizer | BC |
|
|
Kevin Rogers | E&H | DE | Chris Barbour | E&H |
|
|
Chad Burns | R-MC |
|
Mike Fleming | R-MC |
|
|
Philip Hutter | R-MC | LB | Larry Arwood | E&H |
| TE | Derek Jones | E&H |
|
Jeremy Guinn | BC |
| WR | Aaron Settles | H-SC |
|
Tim Armoska | R-MC |
|
|
Junior Lord | GC | DB | Joe Seetoo | R-MC |
| RB | Neal Ferguson | R-MC |
|
Gerald Jones | E&H |
|
|
J.D. Davis | E&H |
|
Thomas Nelson | E&H |
| QB | Sidney Chappell | R-MC |
|
John Benazzi | W&L |
| K | Michael Padgett | BC |
|
Richard Glovier | BC |
|
|
|
|
P | Bryan Esmond | R-MC |
1997
Player of the Year: Sidney Chappell, QB, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Mike Ketchum, GC
| OL | Doug Robertson | GC | DT | Jamie Harless | E&H |
|
|
Philip Hutter | R-MC |
|
Chuck Davis | R-MC |
|
|
Casey Mills | BC | DE | Mike Kassnove | E&H |
|
|
Marc Granger | W&L |
|
Jack Boyd | W&L |
|
|
Mike Hughes | E&H | LB | Chris Li | GC |
| WR | Junior Lord | GC |
|
Larry Arwood | E&H |
|
|
William Rochelle | GC |
|
D'Andre Murray | R-MC |
|
|
Aaron Fuller | E&H | CB | Dusty Beekman | R-MC |
| RB | Oliver Jordan | E&H |
|
Jimmy Lamour | GC |
|
|
Shannon Evans | H-SC | S | Brent Rusnak | H-SC |
| QB | Sidney Chappell | R-MC |
|
Richard Glovier | BC |
| K | Matt Holbrook | W&L | P | Von Lewis | BC |
1998
Player of the Year: Oliver Jordan, RB, E&H
Coach of the Year: Lou Wacker, E&H
| OL | Van Everette | HSC | DT | Isaac Williams | E&H |
|
|
Philip Hutter | R-MC |
|
Chuck Davis | R-MC |
|
|
Temple Musser | E&H | DE | Mike Kassnove | E&H |
|
|
Marc Granger | W&L |
|
Scott Tucker | R-MC |
|
|
Mike Hughes | E&H | LB | Ryan Pitz | H-SC |
| WR | Michael Becker | R-MC |
|
John Carmody | E&H |
|
|
Sean Eaton | R-MC |
|
D'Andre Murray | R-MC |
| TE | Todd Mounts | E&H | CB | Dusty Beekman | R-MC |
| RB | Oliver Jordan | E&H |
|
Chris Ratcliffe | E&H |
|
|
Marc Watson | W&L | S | Tyronn Peterson | E&H |
| QB | Chris. Batcheller | W&L |
|
Will Baker | W&L |
| K | Mike Padgett | BC | P | James Dunton | H-SC |
1999
Player of the Year: Andrew Notarfrancesco, RB, CUA
Coach of the Year: Tom Clark, CUA
| OL | Van Everett | H-SC | DL | Idris Coleman | GC |
|
|
Mike Hughes | E&H |
|
Richard Change | CUA |
|
|
Justin Holton | W&L |
|
Earl Jefferson | E&H |
|
|
Tim McCarthy | CUA |
|
Josh Williams | R-MC |
|
|
Aaron Perkins | R-MC | LB | D’Andre Murray | R-MC |
| WR | Sean Eaton | R-MC |
|
Lonnie Parker | BC |
|
|
Mike Hunter | CUA |
|
Brian Hee | CUA |
|
|
Michael Becker | R-MC | DB | Scottie Brubeck | R-MC |
| RB | A. Notarfrancesco | CUA |
|
Spencer Nice | BC |
|
|
Oliver Jordan | E&H |
|
PeeDee Peterson | E&H |
| QB | Christian Batcheller | W&L |
|
Jimmy Lamour | GC |
| K | Chris Epperly | E&H | P | Chris Epperly | E&H |
2000
Player of the Year: Marc Watson, RB, W&L
Coach of the Year: Mike Clark, BC
| OL | Dan Riley | CUA | DT | Matt Steiner | CUA |
|
|
Tim McCarthy | CUA |
|
Jason Frizzelle | BC |
|
|
Matt Romani | H-SC | DE | Jelani Patterson | E&H |
|
|
Justin Holton | W&L |
|
Ryan Bailey | BC |
|
|
Anthony Church | E&H | LB | Jeff Bahl | W&L |
| TE | Damian Richard | CUA |
|
Nolan Jeffries | E&H |
| RB | Dan Boyle | CUA |
|
Lonnie Parker | BC |
|
|
Marc Watson | W&L | CB | Chris Ratcliffe | E&H |
| WR | Michael Becker | R-MC |
|
James Parker | CUA |
|
|
Nathan Tuck | E&H | S | Chris Scott | H-SC |
| QB | Jason Lutz | BC |
|
Scottie Brubeck | R-MC |
| K | Kevin Cherwa | R-MC | P | Mike Fleet | CUA |
2001
Player of the Year: Jason Lutz, QB, BC
Co-Coach of the Year: Mike Clark, BC
Co-Coach of the Year: Frank Miriello, W&L
| OL | Scott Kucinski | W&L | DT | Matt Steiner | CUA |
|
|
Matt Huffman | BC |
|
Jay Frizzelle | BC |
|
|
Matt Rapoza | W&L | DE | Scott Lutte | CUA |
|
|
Puri Garzone | CUA |
|
Jelani Patterson | E&H |
|
|
Mike Day | BC | LB | Jeff Bahl | W&L |
| TE | Damian Richard | CUA |
|
Phil Christian | E&H |
| RB | Chris Sullivan | W&L |
|
Lonnie Parker | BC |
|
|
Davon Cruz | BC | CB | Lonnie Johnson | H-SC |
| WR | Marc. Richardson | BC |
|
Jay Clark | E&H |
|
|
Chris McKinney | GC | S | Chris Scott | H-SC |
| QB | Jason Lutz | BC |
|
Jimmy Nalls | CUA |
| PK | Brad Wiginton | W&L | P | Mike Fleet | CUA |
2002
Player of the Year: Jermaine Taylor, LB, BC
Rookie of the Year: Clay Muench, WR, R-MC
Coach of the Year: Mike Clark, BC
| OL | Mat Rapoza | W&L | DT | Brian Person | GC |
|
|
Michael Day | BC |
|
Jay Frizzelle | BC |
|
|
Dustin Newman | BC | DE | Ryan Bailey | BC |
|
|
Adam Ward | H-SC |
|
Tiko Williams | CUA |
|
|
Gary Mann | CUA | Rob Tuebner | H-SC | |
| RB | Chris Sullivan | W&L | LB | Jermaine Taylor | BC |
| CW Clemmons | H-SC |
|
Sean Jones | R-MC | |
| WR | Andre Jones | BC | Ben Krasnoff | W&L | |
| Conrad Singh | H-SC | CB | Jay Clark | E&H | |
|
|
Nick Bublavi | CUA | Bobby Akers | R-MC | |
| QB | Hunter Price | R-MC |
|
Chris Scott | H-SC |
| K | D. Van Der Mallie | H-SC | P | Chad Coffey | BC |
2003
Co-Player of the Year: Conrad Singh, H-SC
Co-Player of the Year: Jermaine Taylor, BC
Rookie of the Year: Todd Woods, E&H
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Conrad Singh, Hampden-Sydney
Coach of the Year: Marty Favret, H-SC
| OL | Ranardo Whitaker | BC | DT | Lawrence Frierson | BC |
|
|
Dustin Newman | BC |
|
Jeremy Hagee | E&H |
|
|
Mike Crimmins | CUA | DE | James Riley | H-SC |
|
|
Lee Bailey | H-SC |
|
Tiko Williams | R-MC |
|
|
Phillip Smith | R-MC | LB | Jermaine Taylor | BC |
| RB | Marc. Washington | BC | Bobby Stutz | CUA | |
| CW Clemmons | H-SC |
|
Daniel Park | H-SC | |
| WR | Nick Bublavi | CUA | CB | Steward White | BC |
| Conrad Singh | H-SC | OJ Batts | GC | ||
| TE | Ben Dull | H-SC | S | Jeremy Bradshaw | BC |
| QB | JD Ricca | H-SC |
|
Jeff Inman | H-SC |
| K | Alex Bland | H-SC | P | Christian Adams | GC |
2004
Offensive Player of the Year: CW Clemmons, RB, Hampden-Sydney
Defensive Player of the Year: Lawrence Frierson, DT, Bridgewater
Rookie of the Year: Drew Smith, WR, Hampden-Sydney
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: CW Clemmons, RB, Hampden-Sydney
Coach of the Year: Frank Miriello, Washington and Lee
| OL | Ranardo Whitaker | BC | DT | Lawrence Frierson | BC |
|
|
JD Overton | E&H |
|
Liam Murray | W&L |
|
|
Paul Williams | HSC | DE | Chris Marshburn | RMC |
|
|
David Startsman | W&L |
|
Mike Clark | HSC |
|
|
Paul Getty | HSC | LB | Cam Garvin | BC |
| RB | Chris Miller | E&H | Lloyd Wilson | W&L | |
| CW Clemmons | HSC |
|
Daniel Park | HSC | |
| WR | Colton Ward | W&L | CB | Michael Bryant | RMC |
| Jared Jackson | E&H | Anthony Hunt | BC | ||
| TE | Ben Dull | HSC | S | Adrian Herndon | BC |
| QB | Todd Woods | E&H |
|
Stuart Swann | W&L |
| K | David Blackwell | BC | P | Christian Adams | GC |
2005
Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: J.D. Ricca, Hampden-Sydney
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year, Bobby Stutz, Catholic
Freshman of the Year: Josh Vogelbach, Guilford
Scholar Athlete of the Year: Liam Murray, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Mike Clark, Bridgewater
| First Team Offense |
|
| QB: J.D. Ricca, H-SC | RB: Marcus Washington, BC |
| WR: Nick Bublavi, CUA | TE: Ben Dull, H-SC |
| WR: Drew Smith, H-SC | WR: Chris Barnette, GC |
| OL: Paul Williams, H-SC | OL: Paul Getty, BC |
| OL: Nicholas Reese, BC | OL: Hunter Whitfield, W&L |
| PK: Reggie Moore, R-MC | OL: Zeke Traylor, H-SC |
|
|
|
| First Team Defense |
|
| LB: Brian Gallagher, W&L | LB: Antwaine Campo, BC |
| DL: Chris Marshburn, R-MC | LB: Bobby Stutz, CUA |
| DL: Liam Murray, W&L | DL: Chuck Brown, BC |
| CB: Josh Knight, BC | DL: Thomas Rhone, R-MC |
| Safety: Adrian Herndon, BC | CB: Mark Snoddy, W&L |
| Punter: Travis Frazier, GC | Safety: Jeff Inman, H-SC |
2006
Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Chris Barnette, Guilford
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Marshall Doss, Emory & Henry
Freshman of the Year: R.J. Varner, Washington and Lee
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Jeff Highfill, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Frank Miriello, Washington and Lee
| First Team Offense |
|
| QB: Josh Vogelbach, GC | TE: Dane Williams, H-SC |
| WR:Chris Barnette, GC | OL: Matt Capriani, BC |
| WR: Micah Rushing, GC | OL: Keaton Culver, BC |
| WR: Colton Ward, W&L | OL: Ben Niemaseck, H-SC |
| RB: Charlie Omick, H-SC | OL: Paul Williams, H-SC |
| RB: Winston Young, BC | OL: Hunter Whitfield, W&L |
|
|
|
| First Team Defense |
|
| DL: Tony Burt, BC | LB: Marshall Doss, E&H |
| DL: Matt Baldwin, E&H | CB: Earl Chaptman, BC |
| DL: Gamal Alwan, R-MC | CB: Mark Snoddy, W&L |
| DL: Bryant Fulk, W&L | DB: Desmond Jalloh, BC |
| LB: Brandon Borst, BC | DB: Nick Olivero, CUA |
| LB: Bill Gross, CUA |
|
2007
Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Drew Smith, WR, Hampden-Sydney
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year, Kyle Luby, DB, Washington and Lee
Freshman of the Year: Greg Kurkis, OL, Washington and Lee
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Jeff Highfill, QB, Bridgewater
Coach of the Year: Marty Favret, Hampden-Sydney
| First Team Offense |
|
| QB: Josh Vogelbach, GC | RB: Josh Simpson, H-SC |
| RB: Zac Thornton, R-MC | APB: Stuart Sitterson, W&L |
| WR:Joe Joyner, GC | WR: Drew Smith, H-SC |
| TE: Josh Baumgartner, H-SC | OL: Josh Clawson, E&H |
| OL: Anthony Cotton, BC | OL: Eric Mendel, H-SC |
| OL: Alex Skotnicki, W&L | K: Luke Hawk, E&H |
|
|
|
| First Team Defense |
|
| DL: Matt Baldwin, E&H | DL: Travis Gantt, BC |
| DL: Tom Matteo: W&L | DL: Nate Shook, R-MC |
| LB: Anthony DelBorrell, CUA | LB: Bryant Fulk, W&L |
| LB: Evin O'Sullivan, E&H | DB: Kyle Luby, W&L |
| DB: Mark Snoddy, W&L | DB: Nick Olivero, CUA |
| DB: Kyle Wiggins, R-MC | Punter: Scott Ruebush, BC |
2008
Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Keith Ricca, QB, Catholic
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Nick Olivero, DB, Catholic
Freshman of the Year: Charlie Westfal, QB, Washington and Lee
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Nick Olivero, DB, Catholic
Coach of the Year: Pedro Arruza, Randolph-Macon
| First Team Offense |
|
| QB: Keith Ricca, CUA | RB: Caleb Jenninigs, E&H |
| RB: Josh Simpson, H-SC | RB: Zac Thornton, R-MC |
| WR: Miles Savrick, CUA | WR: Kevin Vaughn, GC |
| APB: Stuart Sitterson, W&L | OL: Charlie Craigle, W&L |
| OL: Jim Gehringer, CUA | OL: Chris Mickno, E&H |
| OL: Ben Rogers, H-SC | OL: Kevin Wagner, R-MC |
| K: Luke Hawk, E&H | |
|
|
|
| First Team Defense |
|
| DL: Matt Baldwin, E&H | DL: Dean Petrone, CUA |
| DL: Dustin Rexrode, E&H | DL: Scott Russell, W&L |
| LB: Bill Gross, CUA | LB: Josh Miller, H-SC |
| LB: Kevin Worley, E&H | DB: Joey Daniels, E&H |
| DB: Chris Killian, BC | DB: Nick Olivero, CUA |
| DB: Chris Prugar, W&L | Punter: T.J. Breslin, CUA |
2009
Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Caleb Jennings, RB, Emory & Henry
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Will Riggenbach, DL, Hampden-Sydney
Freshman of the Year: Daniel Biggerstaff, OL, Guilford
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Greg Kurkis, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Josh Miller, LB, Hampden-Sydney
Coach of the Year: Marty Favret, Hampden-Sydney
| First Team Offense |
|
| QB: Corey Sedlar, H-SC | RB: Caleb Jennings, E&H |
| WR: Sean Cavanagh, H-SC | RB: Thomas Tate, BC |
| WR: Earl Peoples, R-MC | TE: Corey Shepherd, E&H |
| APB: Steve Mathews, R-MC | OL: Rich Brennan, CUA |
| OL: Charlie Craigle, W&L | OL: James Hairston, E&H |
| OL: Ben Rogers, H-SC | OL: Louis Sanchez, BC |
| PK: Josh Storm, R-MC | |
|
|
|
| First Team Defense |
|
| DL: Gamal Alwan, R-MC | DL: Markus Brunson, GC |
| DL: Matt Cassilly, W&L | DL: Will Riggenbach, H-SC |
| LB: Jeremy Bowry, R-MC | LB: Josh Miller, H-SC |
| LB: Andrew Sellers, H-SC | LB: Ed Smith, E&H |
| DB: Darius Burrus, BC | DB: Aubry Dicks, BC |
| DB: Bill Doody, H-SC | DB: Donavon Sawyer, W&L |
| P: T.J. Frazier, E&H |
2010
Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Tyler Beiler, WR, Bridgewater
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Trevor Ikwild, LB, Hampden-Sydney
Freshman of the Year: Mike Pitsenberger, RB, Catholic
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Greg Kurkis, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Frank Miriello, Washington and Lee
| First Team Offense |
|
| QB: Travis Lane, H-SC | RB: Luke Heinsohn, W&L |
| WR: Kyle Vance, H-SC | RB: Caleb Jennings, E&H |
| WR: Earl Peoples, R-MC | WR: Tyler Beiler, BC |
| APB: Harrison Hudson, W&L | OL: Greg Kurkis, W&L |
| OL: Morgan Cross, R-MC | OL: Ben Rogers, H-SC |
| OL: John Fitzgibbons, W&L | OL: George Sheaffer, BC |
| K: David Prizzia, H-SC | |
|
|
|
| First Team Defense |
|
| DL: Ty Condrey, H-SC | DL: Dominic Jeter, BC |
| DL: Jaryd Grimsley, R-MC | DL: Will Riggenbach, H-SC |
| LB: Jeremy Bowry, R-MC | LB: T.J. Montague, BC |
| LB: Trevor Ikwild, H-SC | DB: Jake Pelton, W&L |
| DB: Brandon Mitchell, BC | DB: Daniel Woods, E&H |
| P: Ben Keyser, R-MC | DB: Bill Doody, H-SC |
2011
Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Charlie Westfal, Sr., QB, Washington and Lee
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Devan Sproles, Jr., LB, Emory & Henry
Rookie of the Year: Zac Naccarato, Fr., QB, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Brett Murray, Jr., RB, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Marty Favret, Hampden-Sydney
| First Team Offense |
|
| QB: Charlie Westfal, W&L | RB: Anthony Carter, BC |
| WR: Ben King, GC | RB: Thaddeus Scruggs, R-MC |
| WR: Sean Cavanagh, H-SC | WR: Kyle Vance, H-SC |
| APB: Brett Murray, W&L | OL: Ben Johnson, E&H |
| OL: Will Ferrell, H-SC | OL: Ben Rogers, H-SC |
| OL: Andrew Sloan, R-MC | OL: John Fitzgibbons, W&L |
| K: Josh Storm, R-MC | |
|
|
|
| First Team Defense |
|
| DL: Dominic Jeter, BC | DL: Daniel Preston, E&H |
| DL: Patrick Moses, R-MC | DL: Joe Pricone, R-MC |
| LB: Devan Sproles, E&H | LB: Kenny Fryman, H-SC |
| LB: Jeremy Bowry, R-MC | LB: Rob Look, W&L |
| DB: James Fucillo, CUA | DB: Zach Morgan, H-SC |
| DB: Sean Stewart, H-SC | DB: Jake Pelton, W&L |
| P: T.J. Frazier, E&H |
2012
Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Luke Heinsohn, Sr., RB/K, Washington and Lee
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Joel Francis, Sr., DL, Bridgewater
Rookie of the Year: Matt Pawlowski, Fr., QB, Guilford
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Kyle Boden, Jr., QB, Emory & Henry
Coach of the Year: Scott Abell, Washington and Lee
| First Team Offense |
|
| QB: Nash Nance, H-SC | RB: Luke Heinsohn, W&L |
| WR: Alonzo Cook, CUA | RB: Will McGee, R-MC |
| WR: Holton Walker, H-SC | APB: Brett Murray, W&L |
| TE: Zach Midulla, R-MC | OL: Will Ferrell, H-SC |
| OL:Connor Hollenbeck, W&L | OL: Bobby Jones, W&L |
| OL:Kyle Keister, BC | OL: Byron Overstreet, R-MC |
| K:Max Antwerpes, H-SC | |
|
|
|
| First Team Defense |
|
| DL: Ian Candelaria, R-MC | DL: Vinny Cortese CUA |
| DL: Joel Francis, BC | DL: Danny Grogg, BC |
| LB: Kenny Fryman, H-SC | LB: Jajuan Johnson, SU |
| LB: Andrew Palmer, BC | LB: Robert Smith, GC |
| DB: Steven Fogleman, H-SC | DB: Derrick Gore, BC |
| DB: Jake Pelton, W&L | DB: Satiir Stevenson, GC |
| P: Cory Gay, SU |
2013
J. Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Will McGhee, Sr., RB, Randolph-Macon
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Tyler Ikwild, Sr., LB, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC Coach of the Year: Marty Favret, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Marshall Hollerith, Fr., RB, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Kyle Boden, Sr., QB, Emory & Henry
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Nash Nance, H-SC | RB: Mike Pitsenberger, CUA |
| WR: Adam Smith, GC | RB: Will McGhee, R-MC |
| WR: Holton Walker, H-SC | APB: Andrew Smith, SU |
| TE: Alex Evans, CUA | OL: Will Ferrell, H-SC |
| OL: Michael O'Shea, CUA | OL: Nate Turner, R-MC |
| OL: Connor Hollenbeck, W&L | OL: Bobby Jones, W&L |
| K: Chandler DeHaven, BC | |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Anthony Albanese, CUA | DL: Scott Markland, H-SC |
| DL: Shaq Thomas, H-SC | DL: Tom Solak, R-MC |
| LB: Andrew Palmer, BC | LB: Josh Doggett, H-SC |
| LB: Tyler Ikwild, H-SC | LB: Byron Mitchell, SU |
| DB: Darrick Gore, BC | DB: Satiir Stevenson, GC |
| DB: John Moore, H-SC | DB: Zach Morgan, H-SC |
| P: Tyler Hunt, GC |
2014
J. Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Matt Pawlowski, Jr., QB, Guilford
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Satiir Stevenson, Sr., DB, Guilford
ODAC Coach of the Year: Curt Newsome, Emory & Henry
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Kevin Saxton, QB, Emory & Henry
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Lucas Elliott, Sr., DB, Bridgewater
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Matt Pawlowski, GC | RB: Jacob Wright, BC |
| WR: Adam Smith, GC | RB: Cedrick Delaney, SU |
| WR: Holton Walker, H-SC | APB: Jordan Hartman, BC |
| TE: Steven Quinn, R-MC | OL: Donovan Sudderth, E&H |
| OL: Nate Turner, R-MC | OL: Wes Johnson, GC |
| OL: Micah Fleet, W&L | OL: Nick Powell, R-MC |
| K: Tyler Hunt, GC | |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Kenneth Szabo, BC | DL: Calvin Davis, R-MC |
| DL: Tom Solak, R-MC | DL: Jake Payne, SU |
| LB: Alex Collins, BC | LB: Paul Forney, E&H |
| LB: Hunter Hoots, GC | LB: Josh Doggett, H-SC |
| DB: Darrick Gore, BC | DB: Satiir Stevenson, GC |
| DB: John Moore, H-SC | DB: JerMario Gooch, GC |
| P: Tyler Hunt, GC |
2015
J. Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Matt Pawlowski, Jr., QB, Guilford
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Jake Payne, Sr., DL, Shenandoah
ODAC Coach of the Year: Scott Abell, Washington and Lee
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Kyree Koonce, RB, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Sean Douglass, Sr., OL, Bridgewater
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Matt Pawlowski, GC | RB: Kyree Koonce, H-SC |
| APB: De'Eric Bell, GC | RB: Cedrick Delaney, SU |
| WR: Lucas Morley, CUA | OL: McFarland Murph, E&H |
| WR: Adam Smith, GC | OL: Ty Shwallon, GC |
| WR: Cam Johnson, H-SC | OL: P.J. Melnick, H-SC |
| TE: Keith Jenning, BC | OL: Michael LaSala, W&L |
| K: Skyler Simcox, E&H | OL: Chris Osier, W&L |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Logan Whitaker, BC | DL: Gibson Ziah, GC |
| DL: Xavier Strothers, R-MC | DL: Jake Payne, SU |
| LB: Hunter Hoots, GC | LB: Daytwyn Rascoe, GC |
| LB: Nick Martin, H-SC | LB: Max Garrett, W&L |
| DB: Tre'von Lightfoot, E&H | DB: Robert Smith, GC |
| DB: Sidney Henry, H-SC | DB: Eric Long, R-MC |
| P: Tyler Hunt, GC |
2016
J. Stokely Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Tre Frederick, So., RB, Randolph-Macon
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Cole Burdette, Sr., DL, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Coach of the Year: Pedro Arruza, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Tyriek Russell, Fr., WR, Guilford
ODAC/Virginia Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Max Garrett, Jr., LB, Washington and Lee
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Hayden Bauserman, SU | RB: Tre Frederick, R-MC |
| RB: Cedrick Delaney, SU | APB: Eric Hoy, R-MC |
| WR: Owen Costello, H-SC | OL: McFarland Murph, E&H |
| WR: Michael Ashwell, SU | OL: Ty Shwallon, GC |
| TE: Keith Jennings, BC | OL: Greg Castle, R-MC |
| K: Seth Yurgel, R-MC | OL: Michael LaSala, W&L |
| OL: Chris Osier, W&L | |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Davon Keith, E&H | DL: Gibson Ziah, GC |
| DL: Cole Burdette, R-MC | DL: Xavier Strothers, R-MC |
| LB: Rhasheen Williams, E&H | LB: Hunter Hoots, GC |
| LB: Logan O'Neill, R-MC | LB: Max Garrett, W&L |
| DB: Isaac Evans, BC | DB: Tre'von Lightfoot, E&H |
| DB: Eric Long, R-MC | DB: Will Dyson, W&L |
| P: Jordan Chalkley, H-SC |
2017
J. Stokely Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Cam Johnson, Sr., WR, Hampden-Sydney
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Max Garrett, Sr., LB, Washington and Lee
ODAC Coach of the Year: Scott Abell, Washington and Lee
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Josh Breece, Fr., RB, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Virginia Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Max Garrett, Sr., LB, Washington and Lee
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Hayden Bauserman, SU | RB: Tre Frederick, R-MC |
| RB: Josh Breece, W&L | APB: De'Eric Bell, GC |
| WR: Cam Johnson, H-SC | OL: Wesley Spencer, H-SC |
| WR: Michael Ashwell, SU | OL: Greg Castle, R-MC |
| TE: Patrick Kline, H-SC | OL: Jay Hausler, R-MC |
| K: Jacob Newton, SU | OL: Mitch Hornsby, W&L |
| OL: Chris Osier, W&L | |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Josh Fleenor, E&H | DL: C.J. Nash III, GC |
| DL: Joe Everette, H-SC | DL: Jake Pinkston, R-MC |
| LB: Nathan Campbell, GC | LB: Griffin Davis, H-SC |
| LB: Yonis Blanco, R-MC | LB: Max Garrett, W&L |
| DB: Isaac Evans, BC | DB: Vic Smith Jr., GC |
| DB: Devontae Dunn, SU | DB: Grey Reames, W&L |
| P: Julian Drew, R-MC |
2018
J. Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Hayden Bauserman, Sr., QB, Shenandoah
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Re-Shaun Myers, Jr., LB, Bridgewater
ODAC Coach of the Year: Pedro Arruza, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Kaleb Smith, RB, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Burke Estes, Jr., QB, Randolph-Macon
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Hayden Bauserman, SU | RB: Brian Mann, FC |
| APB: Eric Hoy, R-MC | RB: De'Eric Bell, GC |
| WR: Major Morgan, H-SC | OL: Will Hoffman, BC |
| WR: Casey Stewart, SU | OL: Tyler Weterrings, E&H |
| TE: Sam Tanner, R-MC | OL: Greg Castle, R-MC |
| K: Chris Vidal, R-MC | OL: Jake Wernle, R-MC |
| OL: Mitch Hornsby, W&L | |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Johnathon Johnson, FC | DL: John Kline, H-SC |
| DL: Jarrod Russ, GC | DL: Steve McNair, R-MC |
| LB: Re'Shaun Myers, BC | LB: Griffin Davis, H-SC |
| LB: Bryce Smith, GC | LB: Yonis Blanco, R-MC |
| DB: Matt Dang, BC | DB: Anthony Williams, R-MC |
| DB: Chad Vanlandingham, H-SC | DB: Thomas Freeland, W&L |
| P: Bo Sheridan, W&L |
2019
J. Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Jay Scroggins, Sr., QB, Bridgewater
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Re'Shaun Myers, Sr., LB, Bridgewater
ODAC Coach of the Year: Mike Clark, Bridgewater
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Viante Tucker, Fy., WR, Bridgewater
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Sean Clark, Sr., OL, Washington and Lee
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Jay Scroggins, BC | RB: Tre Fredrick, R-MC |
| APB: Jordan Foster, R-MC | RB: Akiva Wedge, SVU |
| WR: Major Morgan, H-SC | OL: Will Hoffman, BC |
| WR: Derrick Yates, E&H | OL: Tyler Weterrings, E&H |
| TE: Conner Kleffman, BC | OL: Cole Cooksey, BC |
| K: Rhett Andersen, HSC | OL: Will Jackson, R-MC |
| OL: Sean Clark, W&L | |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Josh Fleenor, E&H | DL: Da'von Keith, E&H |
| DL: Andrew Frailerm, W&L | DL: Steve McNair, R-MC |
| LB: Re'Shaun Myers, BC | LB: Ivan Phillips, E&H |
| LB: Gary Ramey Jr., BC | LB: Will Corry, W&L |
| DB: Matt Dang, BC | DB: Nate Hill, SU |
| DB: Calvin Whitehead, R-MC | DB: Neil Davis, SVU |
| P: Grayson Harvey, FC |
2021 Spring
J. Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Presley Egbers, So., QB, Randolph-Macon
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Jay Swegheimer, So., DL, Emory & Henry
ODAC Coach of the Year: Pedro Arruza, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Will Pickren, Fy., DB, Hampden-Sydney
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Tyler Howerton, Sr., OL, Hampden-Sydney
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Presley Egbers, RMC | RB: Demetreus Jalepes, BC |
| APB: Kaleb Smith, HSC | RB: Grayson Overstreet, E&H |
| WR: Elijah Rice, E&H | OL: Dakota Morris, E&H |
| WR: Tmahdae Penn, FC | OL: Brad Gholson, HSC |
| TE: Ed Newman, HSC | OL: Tyler Howerton, HSC |
| PK: Chris Vidal, R-MC | OL: Will Jackson, R-MC |
| OL: Nehemiah Nixon, R-MC | |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Donovan Pinnix, E&H | DL: Aaron Cox, R-MC |
| DL: Jay Swegheimer, E&H | DL: Tyler DeBerry, R-MC |
| LB: Brett Tharp, BC | LB: Brendan Weinberg, HSC |
| LB: Ivan Phillips, E&H | LB: Matt Vegara, R-MC |
| DB: Jaylen Kreimes, E&H | DB: Will Pickren, HSC |
| DB: Ja'Kari Williams, FC | DB: Cade Jones, R-MC |
| P: Patrick Ritchie |
2021
J. Stokeley Fulton Offensive Player of the Year: Justin DeLeon, Sr., RB, Randoph-Macon
Lou Wacker Defensive Player of the Year: Jace DePriest, Sr., DT, Randolph-Macon
ODAC Coach of the Year: Garrett LeRose, Washington and Lee
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Steven Hugney, Fy., QB, Shenandoah
ODAC/Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Jace DePriest, Sr., DT, Randolph-Macon
| First Team Offense | |
| QB: Tanner Bernard, HSC | RB: Justin DeLeon, R-MC |
| APB: Kaleb Smith, HSC | RB: Josh Breece, W&L |
| WR: Tmahdae Penn, FC | OL: TJ Minter, HSC |
| WR: Brant Butler, SU | OL: Connor Denning, R-MC |
| TE: Tim Hanratty, R-MC | OL: Will Jackson, R-MC |
| PK: Chris Vidal, R-MC | OL: Jared Cordova, W&L |
| OL: Logan Moyer, W&L | |
| First Team Defense | |
| DL: Tyler DeBerry, R-MC | DL: Mason Caldwell, SU |
| DL: Jace DePriest, R-MC | DL: Robert Poindexter, W&L |
| LB: Brett Tharp, BC | LB: Brendan Weinberg, HSC |
| LB: Billy Higgins, FC | LB: David Onyejekwe, W&L |
| DB: Chase Rosenthal, BC | DB: Will Pickren, HSC |
| DB: Stephen Richardson, R-MC | DB: Dean Johnson, W&L |
| P: Garrett Graves, BC |