Old Dominion Athletic Conference
All-Time Swimming All-Conference Teams
1983
Coach of the Year: Bonnie Kestner, Sweet Briar
Swimmer of the Year: Karen Fennessey, Sweet Briar
1984
Coach of the Year: Bonnie Kestner, Sweet Briar
Swimmer of the Year: Amy Winder, Randolph-Macon Woman's College
All-Conference:
| Caroline Bays | MBC | Lucy McNichols | MBC |
| Julianne Burkhart | SBC | Susan Drumond | R-MWC |
| Jenny Crossland | SBC | Karen Fennessey | SBC |
| Mary Hollowell | MBC | Debbie Smith | RC |
| Tish Johnson | R-MWC | Dee Smith | SBC |
| Liz McNight | SBC | Norie Smith | MBC |
| Amy Winder | R-MWC |
1985
Note: Swimming was not an ODAC sport in 1985 because there were not enough teams (4) to meet the conference minimum.
1986
Coach of the Year: Bonnie Kestner, Sweet Briar
Swimmer of the Year: Liz McKnight, Sweet Briar
All-Conference (based on coaches' formula):
| Allie Alden | SBC | Donna Meyer | SBC |
| Sharon Bittner | SBC | Liesl Veazy | SBC |
| Jenny Crossland | SBC | Elizabeth Miles | W&L |
| Karen Fennessey | SBC | Frances Williams | R-MWC |
| Lori McGee | SBC | Jenny Morrow | R-MWC |
| Liz McKnight | SBC | Susan Dumond | R-MWC |
| Heidi Metzger | SBC | Amy Winder | R-MWC |
| Colleen Kelley | SBC |
1987
Coach of the Year: Lynda Calkins, Hollins
Player of the Year: Liz McKnight, Sweet Briar
All-Conference (based on coaches' formula):
| Anne Ruggierio | RMWC | Elizabeth Miles | W&L |
| 50 free | 50 free, 100 free, 200 free, | ||
| Heather Logan | W&L | 500 free, 1000 free, 1650 | |
| 50 free, 100 breast, | free, 200 IM, 200 back | ||
| 200 breast | Nancy Whalen | W&L | |
| Debbie Grove | W&L | 50 free, 100 free, 200 free | |
| 100 free, 200 free, 100 fly, | Kathy Stroh | W&L | |
| 200 fly, 200 IM, 400 IM | 500 free | ||
| Kris Amoroso | W&L | Liz McKnight | SB |
| 50 free, 1000 free, | 50 free, 100 free, 200 free | ||
| 100 back | 500 free, 100 back, 100 fly, | ||
| Donna Meyer | SBC | 200 fly, 200 IM | |
| 200 free, 1000 free, 200 | Heidi Metzger | SBC | |
| breast, 100 fly, 200 fly, | 200 breast | ||
| 200 IM, 400 IM | Kristen Austin | HC | |
| Squiffy Walker | SBC | 50 free, 100 free, 200 free, | |
| 200 free, 200 fly, 200 IM, | 500 free, 100 fly, 200 fly, | ||
| 400 IM | 200 IM | ||
| Liz Jones | SBC | Mattie Hodges | HC |
| 1-M dive, 3-M dive | 100 breast, 200 breast |
1988
Coach of the Year: Beth Dalton, Randolph-Macon Woman's College
Swimmer of the Year: Elizabeth Miles, Washington and Lee
All-Conference (picked by coaches):
| Sharon Bittner | SBC | Rachelle Nock | W&L |
| 50, 100 free, 100 back | 50 free, 100, 200 breast | ||
| Heather Logan | W&L | Elizabeth Miles | W&L |
| 50, 100, 200 breast | 100, 200, 500, 1000, | ||
| Kristen Austin | HC | 1650 free | |
| 100, 200, 500 free | Nancy Whalen | W&L | |
| Caroll Dennelly | W&L | 100 free | |
| 100 free | Kristen Wagner | W&L | |
| Kris Amoroso | W&L | 500, 1000, 1650 free | |
| 200 back | Donna Meyer | SBC | |
| Squiffy Walker | SBC | 2000 free, 100, 200 fly | |
| 1650 free | 200, 400 IM | ||
| Debbie Grove | W&L | Sharon Coleman | W&L |
| 100, 200 fly, 200, 400 IM | 100, 200 fly, 100, 200 | ||
| Faren Austin | HC | back, 200, 400 IM | |
| 100, 200 back | Heidi Metzger | SBC | |
| Liz Jones | SBC | 200 breast | |
| 1-meter, 3-meter diving |
1989
Swimmer of the Year: Elizabeth Miles, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Page Remillard, Washington and Lee
All-Conference:
| Kris Amoroso | W&L | Amy Kroeger | SBC |
| Kristen Austin | HC | Heather Logan | W&L |
| Sharon Bittner | SBC | Donna Meyer | SBC |
| Sharon Coleman | W&L | Elizabeth Miles | W&L |
| Carol Dannelly | W&L | Rachelle Nock | W&L |
| Brenda Dolan | R-MWC | Kathy Seraphin | MBC |
| Tina Dunford | W&L | Kristen Wagner | W&L |
| Jodi Herring | W&L | Nancy Whalen | W&L |
| Liz Jones | SBC | Jill Whittaker | SBC |
1990
Swimmer of the Year: Claire Dudley, Washington and Lee
Co-Coaches of the Year: Lynda Calkins, Hollins
Page Remillard, Washington and Lee
All-Conference:
| Farina Austin | HC | Kris Amoroso | W&L |
| Kristen Austin | HC | Sharon Coleman | W&L |
| Matty Hodges | HC | Carol Dannelly | W&L |
| Brenda Dolan | R-MWC | Claire Dudley | W&L |
| Julie Brooks | SBC | Jodi Herring | W&L |
| Holly Fleming | SBC | Rachel Nock | W&L |
| Amy Kroeger | SBC | Stephanie Sauers | W&L |
| Squiffy Walker | SBC | Kristen Wagner | W&L |
1991
Swimmer of the Year: Stephanie Sauders, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Page Remillard, Washington and Lee
All-Conference:
| Stephanie Sauers | W&L | Erica Clayton | SBC |
| Heidi Phillipsen | SBC | Susan Morgan | SBC |
| Sharon Coleman | W&L | Jodi Herring | W&L |
| Claire Dudley | W&L | Farin Austin | HC |
| Jolie Simmons | HC | Squiffy Walker | SBC |
| Michele Niles | HC | Chris Livermore | HC |
1992
Swimmer of the Year: Jodi Herring, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Lynda Calkins, Hollins
All-Conference:
| Christina Buckley | MBC | Jodi Herring | W&L |
| Erica Clayton | SBC | Wendi Knick | R-MWC |
| Stacy Cofield | W&L | Wendy Long | SBC |
| Claire Dudley | W&L | Mary Ruggerio | R-MWC |
| Susan Fisher | W&L | Jolie Simmons | HC |
| Shana Greene | R-MWC | Kerry Thompson | R-MWC |
| Brandi Henderson | W&L | Carolyn yehle | HC |
| Robin Hendrickson | SBC |
1993
Swimmer of the Year: Rebekah Prince, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kiki Jacobs, Washington and Lee
All-Conference:
| Erica Clayton | SBC | Brooke King | HC |
| Cathy Cummings | SBC | Wendy Knick | R-MWC |
| Claire Dudley | W&L | Kari May | W&L |
| Brandi Henderson | W&L | Rebekah Prince | W&L |
| Robin Hendrickson | SBC | Jill Sheets | W&L |
| Susan Fisher | W&L | Jolie Simmons | HC |
| Whitney Wall | HC |
1994
Swimmer of the Year: Jen Miller, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Jerry Salmon, Randolph-Macon Woman's College
All-Conference
| Rebekah Prince | W&L | Anne Spencer | W&L |
| Jennifer Miller | W&L | Erin McKinney | HC |
| Staci Bertelli | W&L | Jolie Simmons | HC |
| Susan Fisher | W&L | Anne Rumney | R-MWC |
| Brandi Henderson | W&L | Cathy Cummings | SBC |
| Laura Marshall | W&L | Robin Hendrickson | SBC |
| Jill Sheets | W&L | Wendy Long | SBC |
1995
Swimmer of the Meet: Rebekah Prince, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Lynda Calkins, Hollins
All-Conference
| Brandi Henderson | W&L | Megan Weidmaier | W&L |
| Susan Fisher | W&L | Bligh Wollner | W&L |
| Taryn Kiekow | W&L | Ginger Cofield | HC |
| Laura Marshall | W&L | Kat Horton | HC |
| Jen Miller | W&L | Anne Rumney | R-MWC |
| Rebekah Prince | W&L | Vanessa Higbee | R-MWC |
| Anne Spencer | W&L | Cathy Cummings | SBC |
1996
Co-Swimmers of the Year: R. Prince, Washington and Lee
Kat Horton, Hollins
Coach of the Year: Kiki Jacobs, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| K. Cruickshanks | W&L | Greta Richter | W&L |
| Margaret Hoehl | W&L | Jill Sheets | W&L |
| Kat Horton | HC | Anne Spencer | W&L |
| Stephanie Kamerer | HC | Courtney Tyler | W&L |
| Taryn Kiekow | W&L | Megan Wiedmaier | W&L |
| Laura Marshall | W&L | Bligh Wollner | W&L |
| Rebekah Prince | W&L |
1997
Swimmer of the Year: Brooke Stanley, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kiki Jacobs, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Brooke Barrier | R-MWC | Lauren McKeever | W&L |
| K. Cruickshanks | W&L | Erin McKinney | HC |
| Courtney Hardt | HC | Greta Richter | W&L |
| Lezael Haynes | W&L | Anne Rumney | R-MWC |
| Margaret Hoehl | W&L | Natasha Sedlock | W&L |
| Taryn Kiekow | W&L | Brooke Stanley | W&L |
| Laura Marshall | W&L | Courtney Tyler | W&L |
1998
Swimmer of the Year: Margaret Hoehl, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: K. Jacobs Moore, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Brooke Berrier | R-MWC | Brooke Burt | SBC |
| Lori Kovatch | SBC | N. Nickodem | SBC |
| Allison Harvey | W&L | Lezael Haynes | W&L |
| Margaret Hoehl | W&L | Taryn Kiekow | W&L |
| Lauren McKeever | W&L | Megan Wiedmaier | W&L |
| Bligh Wollner | W&L |
1999
Swimmer of the Year: Margaret Hoehl, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kiki Jacobs Moore, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Alicia Kemnitz | HU | Lezael Haynes | W&L |
| Brooke Berrier | R-MWC | Margaret Hoehl | W&L |
| Olive Eiley | SBC | Laura Ingoldsby | W&L |
| Lauren Beckenhauer | W&L | Beth Newton | W&L |
| Caitlin FitzRandolph | W&L | Cynthia Smith | W&L |
| Laura Goodwin | W&L | Courtney Tyler | W&L |
2000
Swimmer of the Year: Katie Kennedy, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kiki Jacobs Moore, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Katie Kennedy | W&L | Kelli Austin | W&L |
| Lauren Beckenhauer | W&L | Allison Harvey | W&L |
| Lezael Haynes | W&L | Blair Huffman | W&L |
| Laura Ingoldsby | W&L | Katie Kolle | W&L |
| Lauren McKeever | W&L | Michelle Moore | W&L |
| Cynthia Smith | W&L | Tara Lewis | R-MC |
| Allison Shoemaker | R-MC | Olive Eiley | SBC |
| Lauren Friend | SBC | Brooke Berrier | R-MWC |
2001
Swimmer of the Year: Blair Huffman, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Matt Barany, Randolph-Macon
All-Conference
| Kelli Austin | W&L | Elizabeth Belch | R-MC |
| Jennifer Fallon | W&L | Lauren Friend | SBC |
| Jackie Green | W&L | Wendy Guevara | R-MWC |
| Lucy Heil | R-MWC | Christeen Hodge | R-MC |
| Blair Huffman | W&L | Mandi Kimble | W&L |
| Katie Kolle | W&L | Tara Lewis | R-MC |
| Autumn Matysek-Snyder | SBC | Michelle Moore | W&L |
| Allison Shoemaker | R-MC |
2002
Swimmer of the Year: Autum Matysek-Snyder, Sweet Briar
Rookie of the Year: Lourdes Cuellar, Randolph-Macon Woman's College
Coach of the Year: Bonnie Kestner, Sweet Briar
All-Conference
| Alicia Kemnitz | HU | Elizabeth Belch | R-MC |
| Christeen Hodge | R-MC | Sarah Lutman | R-MC |
| Jennifer Price | R-MC | Lourdes Cuellar | R-MWC |
| Lauren Friend | SBC | Autum Matysek-Snyder | SBC |
| Kelli Austin | W&L | Blair Huffman | W&L |
| Laura Ingoldsby | W&L | Mandi Kimble | W&L |
| Laura Westerman | W&L | Eleanor Williams | W&L |
2003
Co-Swimmers of the Year: Erin Ewalt and Tiffany Pearsall, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Dave Holland, Randolph-Macon
All-Conference
| Elizabeth Belch | R-MC | Tiffany Pearsall | R-MC |
| Sara Hirsch | R-MC | Christeen Hodge | R-MC |
| Erin Ewalt | R-MC | Lourdes Cuellar | R-MWC |
| Jessica Ware | R-MWC | Kristine Holda | W&L |
| Kelli Austin | W&L | Eleanor Williams | W&L |
| Mandi Kimble | W&L | Blair Huffman | W&L |
| Beth Sauer | W&L |
2004
Swimmer of the Year: Erin Ewalt, Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Katie Duff, Randolph-Macon
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Lourdes Cuellar, Randolph-Macon Woman's College
Coach of the Year: Donna Hodgert, Randolph-Macon Woman's College
All-Conference
| Elizabeth Belch | R-MC | Katie Duff | R-MC |
| Erin Ewalt | R-MC | Maggie Frye | RMC |
| Tiffany Pearsall | R-MC | Lourdes Cuellar | R-MWC |
| Kim Edmonds | R-MWC | Brittany Guthrie | R-MWC |
| Jessica Ware | R-MWC | Keturah Akida | W&L |
| Tasia Fisher | W&L | Kristine Holda | W&L |
| Mandi Kimble | W&L | Suzie LaFleur | W&L |
| Beth Sauer | W&L | Abbie Sauter | W&L |
2005
Swimmer of the Year: Erin Ewalt, Randolph-Macon
Co-Rookies of the Year: Sarah Swann, Randolph-Macon / Nicole Snyder, Sweet Briar
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Erin Ewalt, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Jason Gallegher, Sweet Briar
All-Conference
| Maureen McLaughlin | R-MC | Sarah Swann | R-MC |
| Erin Ewalt | R-MC | Heather Portor | R-MC |
| Aimee Powell | R-MC | Randi Smith | R-MC |
| Kim Edmonds | R-MWC | Jessica Ware | R-MWC |
| Nicole Snyder | SBC | Keturah Akida | W&L |
| Emma Axt | W&L | Kristine Holda | W&L |
| Jess Cobb | W&L | Colette Moryan | W&L |
| Amy Roberson | W&L | Abbie Sauter | W&L |
| Brittany Carlton | SBC |
2006
Co-Swimmers of the Year: Erin Ewalt, Randolph-Macon / Kim Edmonds, Randolph-Macon Woman's College
Rookie of the Year: Lindsey Strachan, Washington and Lee
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Erin Ewalt, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Kiki Jacobs, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Maureen McLaughlin | R-MC | Julianne Miata | W&L |
| Erin Ewalt | R-MC | Jessica Shaw | W&L |
| Aimee Powell | R-MC | Randi Smith | R-MC |
| Kim Edmonds | R-MWC | Lindsey Stachen | W&L |
| Lauren Truelove | GC | Susan Mahoney | W&L |
| Shafer Busch | R-MC | Kristine Holda | W&L |
| Jess Cobb | W&L | Amy Roberson | W&L |
| Heather Porter | R-MC |
2007
Swimmer of the Year: Kim Edmonds, Randolph-Macon Woman's College
Rookie of the Year: Marlene Graf, Randolph-Macon
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Amy Roberson, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Dave Holland, Randolph-Macon
All-Conference
| Shafer Busch | R-MC | Maureen McLaughlin | R-MC |
| Amanda Depta | R-MC | Julianne Miata | W&L |
| Katie Duff | R-MC | Aimee Powell | R-MC |
| Kim Edmonds | R-MWC | Amy Roberson | W&L |
| Marlene Graf | R-MC | Jessica Shaw | W&L |
| Hannah Hesser | SBC | Sarah Simpson | W&L |
| Hayley Kennan | R-MC | Hallie Stewart | R-MC |
| Susan Mahoney | W&L | Lindsey Strachan | W&L |
| Jenna Worsham | W&L |
2008
Swimmer of the Year: Lindsay Strachan, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Tess Hayden, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Amy Roberson, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Alex Kuhn, Sweet Briar
All-Conference
| Meredith Bagenstose | R-MC | Amy Roberson | W&L |
| Shafer Busch | R-MC | Jessica Shaw | W&L |
| Corrine Campbell | R-MC | Melissa Simpson | SBC |
| Marlene Graf | R-MC | Sarah Simpson | W&L |
| Tess Hayden | W&L | Jackie Smith | W&L |
| Hannah Hesser | SBC | Randi Smith | R-MC |
| Susan Mahoney | W&L | Lindsay Strachan | W&L |
| Maureen McLaughlin | R-MC | Jenna Worsham | W&L |
| Julianne Miata | W&L |
2009
Swimmer of the Year: Lindsay Strachan, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Lauren Starnes, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Shafer Busch, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Morgan Cordle, Bridgewater
All-Conference
| Lauren Starnes, W&L | Tess Hayden, W&L |
| Jenna Worsham, W&L | Dana Fredericks, W&L |
| Julianne Miata, W&L | Sarah Simpson, W&L |
| Susan Mahoney, W&L | Lynn Bazzel, W&L |
| Lindsey Stratchan, W&L | Brielle Weinstein, W&L |
| Hallie Stewart, R-MC | Sarah Almond, R-MC |
| Corinne Campbell, R-MC | Lara O'Brien, R-MC |
| Shafer Busch, R-MC |
2010
Swimmer of the Year: Sarah Simpson, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Brittany Ross, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Jenna Worsham, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Ellie Shea, Randolph-Macon
All-Conference
| Elizabeth Buckley, R-MC | Ann McCampbell, W&L |
| Rebecca Stevenson, R-MC | Rachel Mensch, W&L |
| Hannah Hesser, SBC | Delaney Rolfe, W&L |
| Lynn Bazzel, W&L | Brittany Ross, W&L |
| Izzy Brassfield, W&L | Katie Salvati, W&L |
| Jocelyn Cassada, W&L | Sarah Simpson, W&L |
| Dana Fredericks, W&L | Elizabeth Starnes, W&L |
| Tess Hayden, W&L | Jenna Worsham, W&L |
2011
Swimmer of the Year: Sarah Almond, Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Tracilyn Babington, Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Delaney Rolfe, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Ben Delia, Randolph-Macon
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Kelly Mae Ross, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Sarah Almond, R-MC | Lauren Kasoff, W&L |
| Tracilyn Babington, R-MC | Elizabeth Plowman, R-MC |
| Izzy Brassfield, W&L | Brittany Ross, W&L |
| Lizzy Buckley, R-MC | Ellie Shea, R-MC |
| Jocelyn Cassada, W&L | Rebecca Stevenson, R-MC |
| Ann McCampbell, W&L | Michelle Szymczak, W&L |
| Dana Fredericks, W&L |
2012
Swimmer of the Year: Emma Phillips, Greensboro
Rookie of the Year: Caroline Hamp, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Delaney Rolfe, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Simone Conyers, Bridgewater
All-Conference
| Sarah Almond, R-MC | Joanie Hudak, W&L |
| Maggie Dwyer, HU | Lauren Kasoff, W&L |
| Izzy Brassfield, W&L | Virginia Mauch, R-MC |
| Lizzy Buckley, R-MC | Kellianne Mullin, R-MC |
| Jocelyn Cassada, W&L | Emma Phillips, GREEN |
| Caroline Hamp, W&L | Delaney Rolfe, W&L |
| Dana Fredericks, W&L | Brittany Ross, W&L |
| Meredith Hardy, W&L | Katie Salvati, W&L |
2013
Swimmer of the Year: Caroline Hamp, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Emma Swabb, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Delaney Rolfe, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Fran Smith, Bridgewater
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Michelle Douglas, Hollins
All-Conference
| Lauren Frizzell, E&H | Hannah Melkun, W&L |
| Taylor Guardalabene, E&H | Colleen Moore, W&L |
| Tyler Herron, E&H | Izzy Brassfield, W&L |
| Payton Shirey, E&H | Stephanie Foster, W&L |
| Emily Maltby, R-MC | Meredith Murphy, W&L |
| Rebecca Stevenson, R-MC | Delaney Rolfe, W&L |
| Caroline Hamp, W&L | Brittany Ross, W&L |
| Meredith Hardy, W&L | Emma Swabb, W&L |
| Lauren Kasoff, W&L |
2014
Swimmer of the Year: Allison Fowler, Emory & Henry
Rookie of the Year: Michaela Nolte, Emory & Henry
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Stephanie Foster, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Jason Gallaher, Sweet Briar
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Morgan McKinnon, Guilford College
All-Conference
| Marisa Martinez | GREEN | Stephanie Foster | W&L |
| Allison Fowler | E&H | Sydney Gay | W&L |
| Taylor Guardalabene | E&H | Caroline Hamp | W&L |
| Liz Kleveno | E&H | Meredith Hardy | W&L |
| Michaela Nolte | E&H | Elisabeth Holmes | W&L |
| Jessica Richardson | E&H | Lauren Kasoff | W&L |
| Payton Shirey | E&H | Jillian Leigh | W&L |
| Emily Plowman | R-MC | Emily Rollo | W&L |
| Megan Monahan | SBC | Emma Swabb | W&L |
2015
Swimmer of the Year: Emily Rollo, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Kira Tomenchok, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Stephanie Foster, Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Dave Griffore, Emory & Henry
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Jessica Richardson, Emory & Henry
All-Conference
| Allison Fowler | E&H | Cassidy Fuller | W&L |
| Taylor Guardalabene | E&H | Kaitlyn Gardner | W&L |
| Michaela Nolte | E&H | Sydney Gay | W&L |
| Jessica Richardson | E&H | Elisabeth Holmes | W&L |
| Natalie Brendsel | W&L | Emily Rollo | W&L |
| Stephanie Foster | W&L | Kira Tomenchok | W&L |
2016
Swimmer of the Year: Michaela Nolte, Jr., Emory & Henry
Rookie of the Year: Elle Chancey, Fr., Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Stephanie Foster, Sr., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Emily Townsend, Sr., Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Michaela Nolte | E&H | Elisabeth Holmes | W&L |
| Jessica Richardson | E&H | Haylee Rademann | W&L |
| Claire Webber | HU | Emily Rollo | W&L |
| Kata Kylliainen | R-MC | Sarah Schaffer | W&L |
| Elle Chancey | W&L | Emma Swabb | W&L |
| Cassidy Fuller | W&L | Kira Tomenchok | W&L |
| Jordan Watson | W&L |
2017
Swimmer of the Year: Emily Rollo, Sr., Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Ali MacQueen, Fr., Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Michaela Nolte, Sr., Emory & Henry
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Dani Raymond, Jr., Hollins
All-Conference
| Michaela Nolte | E&H | Taylor Ecleberry | W&L |
| Jessica Richardson | E&H | Emily Hageboeck | W&L |
| Kelly Amar | W&L | Elisabeth Holmes | W&L |
| Laura Bruce | W&L | Ali MacQueen | W&L |
| Elle Chancey | W&L | Halyee Rademann | W&L |
| Katherine Degner | W&L | Emily Rollo | W&L |
| Jordan Watson | W&L |
2018
Swimmer of the Meet: Emily Hageboeck, So., Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Meet: Mattie Grant, Fr., Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Emily Hageboeck, So., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Sarah Ahson, Fr., Sweet Briar
All-Conference
| Kata Kylliainen | R-MC | Taylor Ecleberry | W&L |
| Kacey Pool | R-MC | Hannah Freibert | W&L |
| Laney Sanchez | R-MC | Mattie Grant | W&L |
| Reilly Bird | RC | Emily Hageboeck | W&L |
| Kelly Amar | W&L | Ashley Johnston | W&L |
| Elle Chancey | W&L | Ali MacQueen | W&L |
| Katherine Degner | W&L | Jordan Watson | W&L |
2019
Swimmer of the Meet: Emily Hageboeck, Jr., Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Meet: Caroline Baber, Fr., Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Emily Hageboeck, Jr., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Brent Kintzer, Randolph-Macon
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Kelley Hilliker, Sr., Bridgewater
All-Conference
| Lindsei Hamilton | R-MC | Laura Bruce | W&L |
| Kata Kylliainen | R-MC | Caroline Florence | W&L |
| Reilly Bird | RC | Hannah Freibert | W&L |
| Izzy Mack | RC | Mattie Grant | W&L |
| Kelly Amar | W&L | Emily Hageboeck | W&L |
| Caroline Baber | W&L | Ashley Johnston | W&L |
| Claudia Barnett | W&L | Ali MacQueen | W&L |
| Turner Bobbitt | W&L |
2020
Swimmer of the Meet: Emily Hageboeck, Sr., Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Meet: Sara Gaston, Fr., Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Emily Hageboeck, Sr., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Olivia Heeb-Wade, Sr., Bridgewater
All-Conference
| Claire Galloway | LYN | Jilli Cantrell | W&L |
| Maddie Andrews | RC | Sara Gaston | W&L |
| Reilly Bird | RC | Mattie Grant | W&L |
| Kimberly Large | RC | Emily Hageboeck | W&L |
| Izzy Mack | RC | Ali MacQueen | W&L |
| Caroline Baber | W&L | Laney Vanlenten | W&L |
| Laura Bruce | W&L |
2021
Swimmer of the Meet: Kimberly Large, So., Roanoke
Coach of the Year: Brad Dunn, Lynchburg
Rookie of the Meet: Delaney Kennedy, Fy., Lynchburg
ODAC/Virginia Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Katie Shoaf, Sr., Ferrum
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Hanna DeVarona, Sr., Hollins
ALL-ODAC FIRST TEAM
Corrinn Ford, So., Lynchburg
Claire Galloway, So., Lynchburg
Lindsey Hair, Fy., Lynchburg
Delaney Kennedy, Fy., Lynchburg
Molly Shand, So., Lynchburg
Karolena Steckler, Fy., Lynchburg
Grace Zalkind, Fy., Lynchburg
Maddie Andrews, So., Roanoke
Grace Fountain, Jr., Roanoke
Kimberly Large, So., Roanoke
Izzy Mack, Jr., Roanoke
Hannah Petty, Jr., Roanoke
Maria Vinson, Jr., Roanoke
2022
Swimmer of the Meet: Brynn Martinson, So., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Meet: Brynn Martinson, So., Washington and Lee
ODAC/Virginia Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Claudia Barnett, Sr., Washington and Lee
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Jonathan Taylor, So., Bridgewater
ALL-ODAC FIRST TEAM
Savy Borroughs, Fy., Lynchburg
Claire Galloway, Jr., Lynchburg
Emily Fritz, Jr., Randolph-Macon
Bailey Gallagher, So., Roanoke
Susanna Price, Fy., Roanoke
Acadia ElzHowe, Fy., Sweet Briar
Katharine Alsobrook, Fy., Washington and Lee
Caroline Baber, Sr., Washington and Lee
Claudia Barnett, Sr., Washington and Lee
Turner Bobbitt, Sr., Washington and Lee
Jillian Cantrell, Jr., Washington and Lee
Sara Gaston, Jr., Washington and Lee
Brynn Martinson, So., Washington and Lee
Haley Robinson, So., Washington and Lee
Sophia Rollo, So., Washington and Lee
2023
Swimmer of the Meet: Brynn Martinson, Jr., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Meet: Caroline Russell, Fr., Randolph-Macon
ODAC/Virginia Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Lindsey Hair, Jr., Lynchburg
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Ben Pastva, Jr., Randolph-Macon
ALL-ODAC FIRST TEAM
Claire Galloway, Sr., Lynchburg
Delaney Kennedy, Jr., Lynchburg
Emily Fritz, Sr., Randolph-Macon
Kierra Parsons, So., Randolph-Macon
Caroline Russell, Fy., Randolph-Macon
Katelyn Vieni, Jr., Randolph-Macon
Lily Mullens, So., Roanoke College
Susanna Price, So., Roanoke College
Halle Schart, Fy., Roanoke College
Meagan Baxley, Fy., Washington and Lee
Jillian Cantrell, Sr., Washington and Lee
Sara Gaston, Sr., Washington and Lee
Brynn Martinson, Jr., Washington and Lee
Sophia Rollo, Jr., Washington and Lee
Bella Tarbet, So., Washington and Lee